(coming soon...)
enter your e-mail address
DISCLAIMER
The opinions expressed herein are my own personal opinions and do not represent my Company's view in any way.
Saturday, August 30, 2008 5:47:17 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)

It hasn’t been the best year for Indian cinema. The expected highs sank to lows and the perceived lows lived up to expectation. I’ve mostly felt unchallenged as a filmmaker and deeply disappointed as a cine-goer. There have been few (but far between) silver linings on the bollywood clouds and I feel compelled to list a few.

The Jodhaa-Akbar chemistry was pleasantly surprising. Ashutosh had displayed a tremendous flair of narrative and conviction in his earlier works. His foray into “old world” romance had all die-hard romantics begging for more and Hrithik and Aishwarya gave historic performances (pun totally intended.) The pace was not really the virtue of this film but there were various other cinematic elements that more than made up for it.

Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na. I felt young and depressed when I watched this film. Young because it took me back to the backbench days of my college life and depressed because those days are now a distant memory that high doses of Aspartame are erasing by the hour. I remember seeing the film and then confronting my mirror. I’m worth it so thank god for L'Oréal, now the grays can be covered. Botox is now the next stop. Anyway, back to Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na and the wonderful Imran and Genelia. Imran displayed a casual confidence that made him endearing and eminently watchable. He has great lineage but still stands apart and has an individualistic charm about him. More power to him…. Genelia was fresh, earthy, and rightfully energetic. Here’s an actress waiting to exhale. I hope she makes the right career choices and carves the correct niche for herself. This is almost like a re-launch for her in Indian cinema and I’m sure she will more than live up to all the expectation.

My favorite actor in the whole world is Rishi Kapoor. He was natural at a time when overt, theatric performances were the order of the day. He combated over-the-top and made nuance his strength. Ranbir is a brilliant follow up to a legend. He’s a star and displays all the elements and prerequisites for mainstream lead roles. Hidden beneath the controlled body language and nimble dance abilities definitely lies an actor. I’m dead sure in years to come that Ranbir will emerge as an “actor/superstar”, a very rare combination.

Rock On is by far the best looking film of this year. Jason West captures the mood of a rock concert with unbelievable expertise. This brave endeavor is a huge technical victory and a lesson to learn for all of us filmmakers. The production design, ambience, and styling are pitch perfect. Farhan and Arjun were born to be rock stars and it almost seemed like their childhood dreams came true on celluloid. Special mention must go to Shahana Goswami who displayed the best piece of acting I think I’ve seen in years. Excel Entertainment (headed by Ritesh Sidhwani and Farhan Akhtar) definitely needs a pat on their backs for continuing to consistently be cinematically progressive.

So that’s all I liked this year. There’s a lot I didn’t care for but I’m just somebody who likes to focus on the good, and hope the bad gets better. I’m now waiting for the crème of the fraternity to shine on Eid, Diwali and Christmas. Fingers crossed.

Love and koffee,

Karan.

p.s. Heartiest congratulations to Ram Gopal Varma and his sleeper hit “Phoonk” I haven’t seen it (and don’t plan to) but still feel congratulations are in order. Also, I get a lot of enquiries and comments about “My Name is Khan.” I’m afraid to talk about it and divulge too much as the film is still very nascent in its stage but please stay connected and thanks for all the interest.

Comments [212]     

Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:08:38 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Two things:

You said Ranbir is a rare Star/Actor combn...Isn't Sharukh a good actor/Star?

Didn't you like Om Shani Om?
SMK
Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:11:45 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan, im a huge fan , the first Indian movie that i've ever watched was KANK .. and since then i became a huge fan of Bollywood and Karan Johar..

I'm waiting for Dostana .. and i'm always 100% sure of your work ;)

I totally agree with you.. Jodha Akbar and JTYJN were the best movies this year, although Jodha Akbar was quite a long movie but Ashutosh made it certainly entertaining, i didn't feel bored at any moment while watching it.

JTYJN .. is a very clever attempt in the Comedy/Romance category that Bollywood movies are specialized in. It was totally enjoyable.

I'll try watching Rockon today.. it got many positive reviews so far.

I would like to thank for all the great movies .. and i hope you visit Dubai very soon .. Wish u all the goodluck.

Abdalla.

Abdalla J.
Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:17:55 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi sir u must not remember me i know **
sir don`t get so much upset with bollywood
i loved rock on ;jaane....
and what so ever best is yet to com we are waiting
for rab ne ...,billoo barber...duniya jaye var main if our camp is
doing well then bollywood is also doing well that`s it
sourav
Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:17:57 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
All the best for all your endeavours
Manjiri
Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:22:05 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hey karan.
today i think I am the first one,who is going to comment here.
we are always with you dear, hopr that bilobarber-dostana clash is a media made bulshit and there is nothing wrong between you and Sharukh. eventhough the moveis clash with each other, whats wrong with that.thats ok and both films do well. any how first i would love to congratulate you for the buzz that first promo of dostana made. then i think you are planing the film khan, seroiusly cant wait for that. hope you will release that film in next year. loving regards to you,your mom and your family-film faternity.
ALL THE BEST.
shereen
Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:31:18 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan

Reading your blog is always so refreshing as you say things just as they are and don't add any extra "spin" to it!

I too thought this year was not a good year for Bollywood..........but as they say.......things can only get better!!!

Personally for me my favourite film this year has to be by far Sarkar Raj! I just think the performances were superb!

I saw the trailer to Dostana, me and my friends can't wait for it to be released! I love seeing Abhishek Bachchan doing comedy.......I loved his special appearance in Salaam Namaste!

Obviously the main attention for me is My Name Is Khan (which I cannot wait to hear more about)!

Can't wait to read your next blog entry!

Kind regards

Munpreet Kaur Mangat
Birmingham, UK
Munpreet Kaur Mangat
Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:32:04 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan!
Thank you so, that you find time to write in blog, and that it causes in you interest. I hope, that interest remain still for a long time.

I have an opportunity to look only Jodhaa-Akbar. It is necessary much more time to search other films .
Now I cannot express my opinion concerning all films specified by you. But I am sure, that I can do it a little bit later.
In Russia this year is poor harvest also ( cinema harvest). If to compare with 2007, I would name 2008 as hungry on the good cinema made by Russian authors.
Whether the dilemma always takes place: commercial success or creativity?
Mine top 5 for 2008 (not created, but seen)
1. "Returning" by Almodovar. I love this film. I love how this history was told.
2. " The Life of others "
3. " Malvin's room " with Meryl Streep ( I really love her)
4. Kal Ho Na Ho
5. Swades

I have exposed films on chronology, not on a degree my adoration of their.
I shall not ask you about " My name is Khan ".
When the project only is started, we can be superstitious.
Besides, I do not like to tell about something in details, that exists only in my imagination, as idea or the plan.
When I tell to someone about the plan, there are some problems with his realization after.

Have a nice day,
with sincerity,
Ann
Russia, Rostov-on-Don


Saturday, August 30, 2008 6:50:41 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
At last ....keep your blogs coming a little faster...know you are a busy man...but love reading your blogs.
Ranjani
Saturday, August 30, 2008 7:04:39 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi dear,
I hope u r fine.
my name is karan would be a hit, a megahit.
"changes r the law of nature"

amor vincit omnia

arun
Arun Menon
Saturday, August 30, 2008 7:07:32 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Sir,

With due respect I wish to add on. I wonder how much it has to do with the changing dynamics of Exhibition and Distribution. More Multiplexes, More digital screens, above the top marketing on Television Channels, Internet, and International revenues . Price discovery through different revenue streams is again a big challenge. In film Branding, Satellite rights, Internet, Digital Music and Home Video are subsidising the recovery in a big way.

What can be a concern is escalating Talent fees and lower per print earnings. Isn't the box office collections walking a tight rope?

Unless the theatres give value for money in a sense of Visual appeal and dynamic sound with a story to back up its going to be more and more difficult to bring audiences to the Multiplexes each week after another.

In my opinion unless we bring 2k / 4k digital projections and a release of more than 2000 prints backed up with VFX Screen plays, crossing regional barriers and targetting global audiences the industry is continue to witness Roller Coaster Rides now and again.

Sir, We all have witnessed and appreciated the Visual Appeal in watching your productions in Theatres and the repeat value of course.

Vinod Agarwal - Aspiring Assistant Producer




Saturday, August 30, 2008 7:24:50 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan,
I feel nothing by far has been so good as the year 2006 was.
2006 marked in bollywood the year for all genres a year for all movie-goers.2006 was definitely a remarkable year,
we had Munnabhai, Rang de basanti ,Kabhi alvida naa kehna ,Don,Krissh to name a few
i asked you regarding your work interest in MADHURI .i am desperate to see her in a DHARMA movie
hoping you to read this.
Love andLloads,
Manas G. Pahaariya
Saturday, August 30, 2008 7:41:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
karan ,

I am eagerly waiting for the movie " My name is khan "

I have read in the deccan chronicle that madhavan is acting as sharukh brother and shabana azmi as sharukh mom and kajol as shahrukh wife.

It is true or it is just the rumor.

If it is true , the cast is fantastic.

I am eagerly waiting for your reply

Cheers
Vijay
(pvijay@y7mail.com)
vijay
Saturday, August 30, 2008 7:51:58 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan,

yaar thanks loads for the email else i thought that you had forgotten about your blog lekin yaha to itne sare entries hein yaar..m so damn happy else i kept commenting on your first blog only.. pata nehi yeh keise ageya, matlab itne sare entries khair..

karan u r already so handsome yaar trust me, pls dont underestimate yourself.. i love you in everywhich way, be it your physique or personality.. no i'm not exaggerating!! ok if you seriously think dat i am then pls just take a look at the clothes which u r wearing then, none can beat your sense of style! i'm crazy about your taste for clothes, you rock!

i've really appreciated jodha akbar too..apart from your movies, its one of my favourites..inspite of all the controversy it faced, i still believe dat KANK is the best and my perosnal favourite. have not watched JTYJN yet.. but i will surely soon.. jaan ranbir is really capable and will undoubtedly rise as a superstar.. karan all our views are similar lolz.. khair ifever it differs i will definitely tell you ;))

thanks again for the reminder. i'm waiting for the divali release.. ayoo its still a bit far lolz.. again another controversial topic, love your daring attitude ;)) say d trailer and my God, priyanka looks like a real bomb! huh! managed to get her in a swim suit, gosh! :)) lekin personally i wud hv preferred kajol or rani as the actress lekin khair..

likhte likhte i dnt even realize ki itna likh li mein ne..chal phir chalti hou abhi.. i had given up previously, i mean writing regularly kyuki i hd thought ki u hd forgotten abt it.. mast i'll spend my time reading the blogs below.. chal chal katti hu ab lolz..
take care.. keep posting..

kisses and hugs,
love you lots,
smrithee
Smrithee Ramsewak
Saturday, August 30, 2008 7:56:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,
well I think that JTYJN was the best film of 2008 so far. and Ranbir rocked in BAH. but I am looking forward to Rab Ne banadi Jodi. cant wait to see Adi Chopra in the directors chair after so long, that too with SRK.
All the best with MNIK. hope everything goes well with it. and with You.
Luv n Luck,
Sreetama Bose
Saturday, August 30, 2008 7:58:54 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Its really great to know that you take out time to watch most new movies and actually care to count their plus points. Gr8 job.
All the best with MNIK.
Luv n Luck.
Sreetama Bose
Saturday, August 30, 2008 8:07:04 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dude you should be in touch with your fellow bloggers who invest their precious time commentiing on all your posts.
Mr. B's blog you should follow. He makes it a point everynight to respond to the comments he feel are worth of his responses... Okay...?
Take care you.

--
Double 7
Double Seven
Saturday, August 30, 2008 8:12:05 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hey karan
nice to know your views on the releases of de year... But ya as a cine goer even i am dissapointed and for a country where films are a parellel religion i must say it is a let down... but hey 4 more months to go and quite a few promising films linned up... so lets wait and watch....
divya.
divya
Saturday, August 30, 2008 8:21:16 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan...
Thank you for answer for My name is khan. Im so happy you said My name is khan is still very nascent in its stage. Thats Wonderful and I hope we will see SrKajol again in the stage as soon as posible...
love you karan so much...and I will wait to see SrKajol together after 7 years... thats the best news for me ...
T.C Karan...
Saturday, August 30, 2008 8:47:31 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hullo
karan bhaiya

me and my band "BR"{actually is an illusion we only sing for pleasure}
we r really thankful to u fr making our lives bettr to deal wid

i m desperate fr ur upcoming my name is khan....


u make srk a real srk
u r jst awesome
i hope i could get an autograph of urs
u dont reply bt make sure u read it this is my 3rd one
hamza saleem
Saturday, August 30, 2008 8:48:21 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
i do agree there want much to look forward to so far this year

but i loved singh is king and i had more expectattions from bachna ae haseeno but i guess it was a nice time pass im really looking forward to rab ne banadi jodi though that sound amazing and im so excited :).

also karan im really looking forward to my name is khan the title itself sound very intresting and the only thing i need to know is that srk and kajol are in it - thats enough to make me go and watch it and obvcourse that fact that u are directing it ive loved ur films since kkhh because that is the first ever film i saw in the cinema at 8 years old. i remeber imagineing myself in sana saeeds role lol (how stupid i no)

we still have a long wait for my name is khan so im focusing on rab ne banadi jodi xxx

nav
londion
nav
Saturday, August 30, 2008 9:00:03 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Don't think you look like your aging at all ! Atleast not any time soonYes! I too enjoyed jaane tu and JA ll! Wonder what the rest of this years releases will bring! Must catch Rock on if you are recommending it! must be worth a watch!
Good Luck for your future projects! Will there be another season of KWK??
Saturday, August 30, 2008 9:23:15 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I am soo glad that I am the first one yo comment on this blog entry!!
Karan I have to say I love you more than I love any other director or to be true I don't love any other director you are just so much You...

I totally agree with you all I liked this year have been Jodhaa Akbar,Race,loved jaane tu ya jaane na and bachna ae haseeno but you can't forget to mention Singh Is King that movie was greeattt!!!

anyways I am eagerly waiting to see Dostana and Karan you can act I am soo sure about that!

ps: Are we gonna get some more koffee with karan since tv sucks without it!!!

love you
xoxo
rasna bhasin
Saturday, August 30, 2008 9:34:17 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Namaste Karan!


Thank you for keep writing!

Your favorite actor is Rishi Kapoor?Yes, he's really good. I lke his performances in Fanaa and Hum Tum.And he looks very smart.
But my favorite actor is still Shah Rukh Khan.

Don't be afraid to talk about MNIK. I'm sure it will be a blockbuster.
And i'm always looking forward finding any news about it. So please tell something about it.


Please keep writing!
We all love you!

Julia
Julia
Saturday, August 30, 2008 9:37:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Quite agree with you...though haven't watch Rock on yet...but extremely disappointed to see the box office report of Bachna Ae Haseeno...samajh nahi aa raha what's happening to the Indian audiences choice...sometimes they run to completely in the wrong direction...looking forward to watch rock on...thanks for sharing ur point of views with us...it really helps a lot...
Nimmi
Saturday, August 30, 2008 9:45:01 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
interesting blog Karan

the only bollywood movies that I saw for this year is Bhoothnath so far and a song with kareena and then another song from Tashan and i am waiting for October and December :) and thats it for this year


well all the best to you Karan

god bless

love


meshannaluvsrk
Saturday, August 30, 2008 9:47:39 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan.

This year has been kind of strange for movies. I loved Jodhaa-Akbar and JTYJN was decent as well. I have yet to see Bachna Ae Haseeno or Rock On, but would love to. Nothing else really piqued my interest, but just like you, I am optimistic about the future.

I know you can't talk about My Name Is Khan, but maybe you could talk a bit about Gauri Khan? As I said before, I love your friendship and would be interested in hearing more.

Love.
Anita Ramakrishna
Saturday, August 30, 2008 10:08:42 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I check this website everyday to see if you have posted nething new... And I kept consoling myself saying that you were busy with the pre production work of My Name is Khan. I hope my belief was true... Now lemme read what you have written.
Saturday, August 30, 2008 10:10:48 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan can u explain the concept of dishounest hounesty and how to use it in life?And how is it that u deal with people who are not from your walk of life and school of thinking, i find it quite distressing...how should one tackle the problem?

Kaya
Saturday, August 30, 2008 10:12:56 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
You forgot to praise Race, Singh is King and Kismat Konnection. And completely forgot to criticise Aamir and Mumbai Meri Jaan. Isn't Bollywood a place where goons become the kings and sages get crucifixed?

and good luck with My name is Khan, and I am so glad that you're into making at least 4 films a year. Good luck, and please consider arthouse cinema as well.
swapnil
Saturday, August 30, 2008 10:35:22 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan
i am a regular reader of your blog you are a great writer keep on blogging. I am eagerly waiting for 'Dostana' and 'My name is Khan'.as they have two favorite stars in the lead Abhishek and Shah Rukh.
Aditya Deuskar
Saturday, August 30, 2008 10:44:40 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
What the Heck!!! U looooooooooooooooooved OSO saying that it is a typical indian masala flick and a thorough entertainer(and that's y it was da biggest hit of the yr according 2 u). This years biggest hit is SINGH IS KING for particularly da same reason. But u dont wish 2 name it. Strange. Or not really Strange. By da way it has broken the first week record of OSO.
Vicky
Saturday, August 30, 2008 10:49:47 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
thaaaaaaanks karan 4 new blog

& we wante to know about kajol roll in the movie blease


i haete ram gobal verma i dont care about his goulse from u :)
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:00:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karanji,

I love you!!!!! You are my idol!!!!! I love all your films, and I am 99.99% sure that My Name Is Khan will be the biggest hit of 2009 (or whatever year it's going to release).

Is Kajol you favorite actress? She's mine!

Is Shahrukh your favorite actor? He's mine!

I am 95% sure that Dostana will be the hit of 2008.

I love you Karan!!! You're the best director/producer/costume designer/screen player/story writer/script writer

the world's ever had!!!




Best of luck to you for the rest of eternity,
Araliya
Araliya
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:06:11 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I CAN'T WAIT UNTIL MY NAME IS KHAN!!!!!!

I understand you not wanting to talk much about it... my parents are like that too :p

What about U Me aur Hum? Did you see that yet? If you did, how come you didn't mention it? That was such a wonderful movie, and according to Indiafm.com it's rated 4 1/2 stars.

U ME AUR HUM IS AWESOME!!!!!!!

Kajol and Ajay make a superb pair, and the way Kajol portraid her role was speechless.




Lots of love (please don't forget to add U Me aur Hum somewhere in your next post),

Araliya
Araliya
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:17:00 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan,
You are bang on, only a few movies worth watching this year, though I did like Khuda Ke Liye [technicalities - not an Indian film]. I am looking forward to Rock On, some rave reviews. I may catch it after my Swiss vacation...

Oh, just saw some pictures of Hiroo aunty at the premiere of Rock On. She looked lovely !

Later and keep blogging !
Priya
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:17:24 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Loved Rock On, well etched characters and brilliant performances. Waiting for more info on My name is Khan
Bhavana
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:20:15 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hey karan,
i just wanted to ask will you ever cast imran khan in your films??? .........dont think JUST DO IT.........i wud definitely want to see him in yur movie..
with lots of luv
xun..
xun
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:21:36 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I just got back from watching Rock On and it is definately the film of the year so far in my opinion. Also, if you haven't seen Mumbai Meri Jaan, I think you will really enjoy it. What a film and what a performance by Paresh Rawal! I know it's too early to talk about My Name is Khan, right now all eyes are on Dostana. The promo looks good and I was wondering what resemblence, if any, does the film have to Chuck and Larry.
p.s.
On the hollywood front, have you checked out Dark Knight, I would really like to hear your opinion on it because I feel like it's the best superhero movie I've seen.
Kunal
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:27:53 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
"Botox is now the next stop."

Karan, please don't. I think you're good looking without all that. :)

All the very best for "My Name is Khan".
Saturday, August 30, 2008 11:29:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hope ur dostana is brings up the filmy quality of this yr then...! good luck!
Aparna
Sunday, August 31, 2008 12:16:59 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi!

Well yes ,its a great pleasure to watch the movies that are made and some of them have me in awe too.

When movies with young new faces come out it definately takes one to one's own younger days and its obvious to be nostalgic but well thats life. Keep the happy memories alive in whichever way possible. Well you and the others in bollywood have an option of doing so and leave a mark forever.

A big thank you to you who make such movies which is like a dream and teaches us to dream and feel happy. At the end of the day its happiness that matters of self and others around us and you make a good job at it.

Age is something that one has to go through and the more one is calm about it , it stays away from you trust me. Grace is what replaces age and thats the most wonderful thing. :-)

Its always a pleasure to read what you write here and I wonder if you go through the replies we post. :-)

Anyways good luck, stay happy and spread happiness.

Regards
Bubbles
Bubbles
Sunday, August 31, 2008 12:55:18 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I also thought that Thoda Pyar Thoda Mgic was good this year.

I can't wait for My Name Is Khan!
Meera
Sunday, August 31, 2008 12:55:25 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan!

I really think Rock On!! is one of the best movies made in a long time.
I liked a few movies this year (Jodhaa-Akbar, Jaane Tu, Kismat Konnection, Bachna Ae Haseeno, etc) but Rock On!! is really the only movie that I've actually enjoyed completely since Om Shanti Om. I'm sure the year will get better with Billoo Barber, Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi, Dostana, etc.

Hope the MNIK work is going well..All the best!

Lots of love,
Shruti - SRK Super Fanatic
Shruti
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:14:53 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan I think you could not come out of your own Genre. Fact Is that JA is a pathetic film.

I feel You did not mention about Sarkar Raj which is an excellent movie.

Try to admit the good work and other Genres.

I am sure as long as you come out of your own mushy mushy stupid love story kind of genre is good for you.
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:33:34 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
oh karan please tell us when start shooting my name is khan ?im dying to see even one picture from srkajol on the set .i miss them soooo much .pleaseeeee, we cant wait it
love you and srkajol
suzan
Sunday, August 31, 2008 2:00:54 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan phoonk is not yet a hit and will not be a hit it is only self acclaimed by him[RAM]
Adam Abdul
Sunday, August 31, 2008 2:29:20 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan,

i have read your thoughts about JA, JTYJN etc. But i would love to know your opinion about U, Me Aur Hum and the performances of the actors?

Bye
Meltem
Sunday, August 31, 2008 3:15:31 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Fun blog, Karan!! I always enjoy reading your view on the movie industry!! I haven't been able to see Rock On, but I agree on JA and JTYJN! And you still look so good, no botox please.

And I'm quite sure everything will go right with MNIK. Believe me all the fans have waited for so long, prayed so much and we're thrilled to bits it's finally coming. It will be a mega box office!

Bye Saaniya
Saaniya
Sunday, August 31, 2008 4:31:57 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
karan,
Jodha-akbar in some scenes ash looked older i never cared for action. on the other hand hrithik looked like real prince.

jaane naa. old wine in a new bottle. loosely based on a telugu movie nuvee kavali. Genelia acts like a kid who has a low I.Q in almost all the telugu movies. Imran Khan see if he will live upto his first movie marketing sucess.
sharu
Sunday, August 31, 2008 5:48:45 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hello Karen,

Agree with you on Jodhaa Akbar. The movie worked for me mainly because of Ash and Hrithik.
How I wish I could sit down with Gowariker and tell him all the things I wish he had done differently. Like cut out some of the subplots and give us more romance.

Still one of the few enjoyable movies for me this year.
ML
Sunday, August 31, 2008 6:46:10 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan,

When you were talking about Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na I know exactly how you felt. Young and depressed. I'm turning 17 and about to start college in about a year, and when I watched that movie I could really relate to it. It was so fresh so clean so...well youthful. But then the depressing part came I realized that the ages they show I'm only a couple years behind them. Which meant that I'm going to being getting married on like 4-5yrs and that was a very scary thought.

Ranbir Kapoor in "BAH" was AMAZING..intially I didn't like him as much my younger sister, but in "BAH" he definitely won me over! I haven't seen Rock On! yet but hope to see it in the next couple of days. I've been hearing nothing but good things about it.

Take Care.

Khezran
Sunday, August 31, 2008 9:02:15 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan! glad that im the 1st one to comment..

actually, im waiting 4 dostana.. hmm.. can share a lil bit about the movie.. and, actually, please shoot my name is khan in Malaysia! I really hope you can shoot it here, like Farhan Akhtar's Don.. Okay! :)
AyieBoyZ Malaysia
Sunday, August 31, 2008 9:15:28 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
"I’m just somebody who likes to focus on the good, and hope the bad gets better" Soocho woh kabhi nahin ruk passand ("Never stop thinking like that" ... Can you tell I don't speak Hindi)

Nice blog man, keep 'em coming. Good on you for pointing out the positives and strengths of your colleagues and friends.

Cheers,

Imtiaz
ImtiazAA
Sunday, August 31, 2008 9:42:34 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hai Karan,I am one among ur fans.I Really Loved all ur movies(both directed nd produced),except KANK.What were u thinking while making that film ?why srk leaves preity,bçoz she is successful,a nice person and why he likes rani,bçoz she too is a looser like him? what's rani's problem with abhishek.Sorry sir I am more criticising u,but I what can i do,I always want to see a good movie from my favourite director,I don't think it's a bad wish.Bye,Sir.All the Best for Ur next movie.I am really Sorry ,If I said any Thing wrong.
Sunday, August 31, 2008 10:00:50 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
It was so lovely to read this article. You always write from your heart and I like that. I am kinda surprised to know that you felt unchallenged as a filmmaker this year as of now. Jodhaa Akbar which is not only the best film of 2008 so far but also one of the best films of India ever. It was a masterpiece & Hrithik & Aishwarya was fabulous in the film. I am expecting something great like this in your next 'MNIK' !

I liked your KKHH a lot , liked K3G also but in parts but I was little bit disappointed with KANK. I am very sure I am gonna watch a great film in your next 'My Name Is Khan'. Can't wait to see Shahrukh-Kajol once again . It would be nice if we see Hrithik-Aishwarya in any of your films. They are the best on screen couple I have seen after SRK-Kajol.

Best of luck for your next productions & your own film 'MNIK'.

Regards
Sultan Mahmud
Dhaka (Bangladesh)
Sultan Mahmud
Sunday, August 31, 2008 10:07:40 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan

Its always a pleasure to read your blog. Your comments regarding the current trend or rather the new films in Bollywood are spot on.

I agree with you that there are not many good films at the moment in 2008 and that is the reason why I am waiting for your 'My Name is Khan' SRK and Kajol. My farourite pair.

I have not watched Jaane......but the movie clips and music sure made you want to watch it. You are so right... it sure reminds me of the good ole days ... missing the easy carefree life - no responsibilities,

As for your film Dostana I will definitely watch it if not on the big screen then DVD in the confines of my home.

Karan, do us bollywood fans a favour - pleasssse try to patch SRK and Salman as they both have strong fan base. They are behaving like kids. It does not matter who is right or wrong but for the good of the industry and their reputations it would be good to let bygone be bygone. Anyway, when someone had a bit too many drinks they tend to say, do silly things which will embarrass them BUT once they are sober they should really 'kiss & make up', I know its wishful thinking BUT you never know when it comes to BOLLYWOOD...

Have a great weekend and till your next news..

LilinS





































lilins
Sunday, August 31, 2008 10:52:31 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
i quite agree with ur review of dis year's movies.d only ones which impressd me r rock on,bachna ae haseeno,jaane tu ya jaane na n singh is kinng..eagerly waiting for dostana n ofcourse my name is khan...
saumyata
Sunday, August 31, 2008 11:00:14 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey

Keep blogging even tho my cooments aren' there I still read .....
Will wait anxiously for some news on MNIK.. Pls do something to ease the rift bet th 2 gr8 KHANS
Luv
Susan
Susan
Sunday, August 31, 2008 11:42:49 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan....

Loved the thoughts on the movies......i simply enjoyed Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na...reminded me of my college days..hmmm i feel old now lol...okay aside from that Rock On promos look brilliant n the music is amazing....Hope Dostana does really welll...n iam definitely one to look forward to watch it first show....

Wel lots of wishes for Dostana and read more about film fraternity from you.

adios
pinks
pinks
Sunday, August 31, 2008 12:01:22 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
SIR....U told ur ponit of view about all the recent past movies but I really didn't understand what U actually ment to say about the flick Jaane tu... what is actually thr to get depressed, it's about a particular phase of lyf when U r just trying to njoy whats coming your way.
and can YOU PLEASE GIVE MORE INFORMATION ABOUT UR NEXT FILM (DOSTANA)...i AM REALLY CURIOUS TO KNOW ABOUT IT
Sunday, August 31, 2008 12:13:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Finally Karan! That post was a long time coming, you really need to write almost everyday because your fans are very impatient!
Sunday, August 31, 2008 12:19:24 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
i totally agree with u karan.. this wasn't a great yr as far as movies r concerned.. i haven't seen rock on as of now but i do think it will b the best hit movie of the year as im an ardent fan of farhan akhtar.. hi hope dostana adds 2 the list of the better made movies this year.. the promos look fantastic! all the best!
anya
Sunday, August 31, 2008 12:25:56 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hiiiii karan,

i like dis post of your's. but why do u write after a long gap. i keep waiting. even if i hav exams i keep on checking dat wether u dere is any post from u. well, i liked all d same above dis year. but i am eagerly waiting for rab ne and dostana obviously.

with lots of love n best wishes for ur upcoming projects,

angana
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:09:15 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

Wow, im so happy to know that im the first lucky person to comment of your recent fabulous blog... i have been keeping track of all ur entertaining and intelligent blog entries. What can i say about you Karan, you are such a honest, witty, clever and respected person with so much pride that i admire and look up to your zest for life that you have. I wud love to b more engaging and communicating and enjoyable person as you because you are so loved by everyone and i was shocked to hear that you used to be extremely shy and an introverted person before because i am like that myself but seeing you as a great example on how we shud b people persons, i have started to change myself by being more out there, trying new thingz n being more approachable to others and i admire you, as you said that on ur show Koffee with Karan which i jus loved and miss it now that itz off air but i still see re-runz as they are still very exciting and fun with ur persona and gud sense of humor that u have that i jus love to death... lol!!! I jus love all ur movies from ur first Kuch kuch hota hai (which was such a fresh and entertaining movie still now, i watched it while growing up and fell in love with kajol even more), k3g (what a great star-cast with gud roles that are still stuck in my mind and great feel gud emotions that touched my heart deeply and great comic moments, i have lost count how many times i have watched it), Kal ho na ho (great performances by Priety and Srk and also Saif and great moving story n great music with the title song that still makes me cry) and your most accomplished and brilliant movie til date Kabhi Alvade na kehna (what a brave task you took and handled the subject with elan with great majority and powerful performances by everyone) and im looking forward to many more great movies of you Karan, especially for My Name is Khan, i cant wait anymore coz im dying to see my fav. all-time pair of Kajol n Srk together on screen to create magic again... n i wish you all the best n don’t b pressured by the task coz all your fans will appreciate your film no matter wat. You don’t have to spill anything bout My name is khan yet coz it is better to wait til the right time inorder to keep the excitement and surprise on hold when the date of the release comez closer. Also can you plz inform all your fanz about when Koffee with Karan Season 3 will start coz i cant wait to see you back on ur chatshow as im missing all the fun and wit u bring on tv? i also agree with all of gud line up of movies that you chose as ur fav. of 2008 so far, as u do have gud taste n i agree with ur comment of each of as i personally loved all the films too mentioned above but why were other great movies Race and the best performance of Ajay n Kajol U, Me Aur Hum missing in the list, jus curious? Also can u plz cast Vidya Balan in ur nex film, i jus love her SO MUCHHH as she is truly so beautiful n talented and also can u cast Imran Khan in atleast in one film of urs and also Genelia, shez jus amazing!!! I also admire the fact that u still congratulated the scary monster ram gopal verman bout his tacky film as that makes you the better person whom i respect a lot with the kind gesture you showed to him, n even im not planning on seeing his crazy movie… lol!!! Also don’t worry about your look and aging Karan, you still look young n dashing and verging to live life to the maximum… as long as ur heart is young, u got nothing to worry bout (which I can comment on further as u are very young at heart and enjoy life). I hope one day I get to meet you in person as you have such a great personality and great sense of humor and im sure we wud get along really well… u seem like a great fun and loving person whom we need more of in this big bad world. Sorry I went on to write a long story Karan but I was keeping all of this inside me and now itz finally out 4 ur earz n seez to see the love n support u have from this small little number one fan of urs n ur movies in Canada. Plz can u mention me in jus one of ur blogz n plz answer some of my questions, it wud jus make my day hearing from you, Karan… or can u atleast email me at my email account, malikshah03@hotmail.com… I wud love to chat bout cinema and movies and about life in general with you… keep in touch and wish you all the success and happiness in life and all best to you in the future and keep rocking and spreading the positively and humor that I cherish the most about your great personality. Also, plz blog more often pleaseeeee!!! Also cant wait to see Dostana looking interestin n Priyanka Chopra is looking ultra gorgeous in the golden bikini and tell her that me, Shahzeb from Canada is mad about her and jus LOVES her TOO MUCHH!!!

P.S. First, I didn’t like drinking koffee b4 but now I jus love drinking koffee so much coz of u and also I only spell koffee wit a K now, itz all ur fault Karan, thanx a lot… LOL!!!!! Luv you n u rock KARAN!!!!

From your number one biggest fan and admirer from Canada,

Shahzeb
Shahzeb
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:13:25 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi...
To be very honest i think jaane tu yaa jane naa has been the only film which has been recieved really well.At times due to a lot of hype there are some flicks who turn out to a major hit n yet one can find that people dont have nice words for them...they just go for it because everyone else is going or there is a major hype around it....I feel that for a film maker the best thing on this earth might be when people have a speacial place for their work in their hearts...like Chak De India...Taare Zameen Par....which really turn out be the ones who touches the heart of every cinegoer...From your side i really loved kal ho naa ho,kuch kuch hota hai and kabhi alvida naa kehna....(i tought it was a brave attempt but maybe people are not ready for it...or they are hyppocrates...or maybe not brave enough to come out in open and say that i liked this film because a majority is criticizing...so they dont want to feel out of place...god knows better....)
priyamvada
priyamvada
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:13:41 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi Karan
Shahzeb
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:16:00 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Why don't you come out of the love angles and give shape to a conciousness that lead us to think and act for a larger cause? I am not talking about terrorism or corruption but something else. The world is not looking up to someone who at the peak of his dreams and career is taking Koffee but someone who though is sittiing at the 'ivory' tower, is truly sensitive to their problems, that is eating away their confidence. I'm sure all the brothers and sisters who regard you, will feel the same.

Try being a different Karan! You will make a mark.

Regards
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:30:14 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hmm.. good to hear ur views on recent releases..well i totally agree wd all ur POV'S regarding jaane tu..rock on.. nd ranbeer bt frankly speaking our indian audience r still unable to connect themselves with rock on kind of urban bkdrop movie.. its vry multiplex cinema.. bt i m really loving it.. evn i saw bachna.. and it has again took us bak to those raj simran days of DDLJ.. ohh godd i cnt tell u , hw mch i like ddlj...its like an epic ..like sm routine wrk whch evry cinegoer shud go through.. i quite like ranbeer nd imran..bt i doubt tat imran cn match upto ranbeer's excellence.. lets c..
well saw ur dostana teaser on dharma productions website.. so far lookin good .. fresh nd quite funny... jst waiting fr its release.. nd looking frward fr my name is khan..
its really tough tie fr u karan cz there r loads n loads n loads of xpectation frm u.. and i hope u will prove urself again...
one more thing.. i jst waant u to again recreate the magic of KKHH...plzz plzz plzz plzz plzz plzz plzz plzz plzzzzzzzz ,... smthing new fresh vibrant..nd vry genuine kind of love story... i hope u will gve ur ear on ths..
loads of love....
SHARAD.
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:38:22 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
You seem to be anxious and its all natural to feel so, since the movie from your production house is going to be released soon and you have MNIK's work also on your hands. DON'T WORRY, it all will turn out in your favour and your stars and the stars in your films will shine really bright as you work really hard.....I mean you take care of every thing about your films very nicely and there is a lot of faith in your work.

Best of luck!

with best regards.
s.sharma
p.s. please don't take so many days to update your blog. you can write about anything or everything but please don't take long.This is a request.
s.s.
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:42:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Mithya
Any list of 'good' films in 2008 cannot be completed without mentioning this one film.
By contrast, hollywood gave us a summer to die for this year.
Chaitanya
Sunday, August 31, 2008 1:54:06 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
salam from malaysia.
may Allah give you the best idea and creativity for your up coming film-MNIK.
lots of love
saiya
Sunday, August 31, 2008 2:51:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Sweety,

Hoping to be the first one to comment on this blog....but im too sure....anyway....good to hear from you after a really long time.....
all smiles for this one too...........

I loved it........I feel again that i am reading myself.....

ALSO, love you for your honest reaction towards RGV.....

Many things to write but i cant find the words......

I know you are damn busy and tied with your work but please please please try and write more often if you find tiniest of the time.

Love You as always.....

Yours and only yours

Chilli......
Chilli
Sunday, August 31, 2008 3:00:55 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
HEYA!I I GUESS JANE TU YA JANE NA WAS THE ONLY MOVIE WHICH WAS ABLE TO ATTRACT A BIG CROWD TO THE "CINEMA HALLS"AND ROCK ON IS FOLLOWING UP ESPECIALLY IN METROES.
I DONT KNOW WHY CANT WE SEE THAT OLD CRAZINESS AMONG THE AUDIENCE LIKE IT USED TO BE 5-10 YEARS AGO..!!
IS NO FILMMAKER ABLE TO CREATS THAT OLD MADNESS??
Sunday, August 31, 2008 3:08:15 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I would like to congratulate you on your success for this year. I hope all your hopes and wishes for your projects will continue to be realized.
Rishi Kapoor is also one of my favourite actors - I have watched all of his movies, so I am not surprised that he is one of your too!!
I am also looking forward to Eid and Diwali. I hope that my best friend's (Kokila) and my duas (mine especially during Ramadaan) are accepted that would change both our lives.
I hope that some of yours would also be accepted.
One of my duas is related to a registered letter that I had sent to you, which I hope that you had received with regard to Shah Rukh Khan.
If not, I will keep my fingers crossed that you will receive my email to you.
Fathima Jani
Sunday, August 31, 2008 3:23:03 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hello Karan,

It is nice to read a new post from you. Bollywood it seems is making more films in quantity rather than quality. Numerous times the filmmakers are more interested in launching new faces, leaving behind the more established ones. I will never understand why Bollywood thinks an actress is too old when she is in her late 20s.

I am sorry but I do not waste my money and time in the cinema with the unknown faces. The reason why many, many are awaiting for MNIK is because of the star casts and of course you being the Director.

God bless you.
RS
Sunday, August 31, 2008 3:49:24 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
yes my comment will b first 4the 1st time.....dont censor it....well,i never saw any of t movies u mentioned above.....i shd b COMEPELLED TO GOOOOO.it rearly happens....until its your direction n story......no dostana too wont force me to go.....yes mynik will definetly.....whats the height of horror karan????????? RGV N KARAN JOHAR sitting together n watching dhoonk....oops i mean bhoonk oops again i meeen ........dar de mare na pulgaee.....oops.......
kavita
Sunday, August 31, 2008 4:10:41 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
HIIIII Karan!!!!!!!!!(please forgive the extra exclamation marks...i'm just soooo excited that you might actually read this.)
I really love your movies and have seen Kuch Kuch Hota Hai about 17 times(still counting..) and even though you didn't direct Kal Ho Na Ho...that's my favourite....Anyhow, I saw the promo of Dostana and it looked like a comedy.....I read you really like-sorry.. admire Rishi Kapoor...who else do you like??... and how does it feel being one of bollywoods leading actors??!!...
At the thought of boring you....i'll just stop(may be after a few more lines...)..I hope you reply soon..
P.S.-could you ask Shahrukh Khan to also join the blogging world...
Bye.
iluvmovies
Sunday, August 31, 2008 6:09:31 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan, I am curious to know what you thought of Mithya and Mumbai Meri Jaan, if you have seen them...
Love
Pratim
Sunday, August 31, 2008 6:34:17 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
DEAR KARAN

HI !! WHAT A LONG KOFFE BREAK YOU TOOK BETWEEN ABOVE BLOG AND DOSTANA PRO BLOG

WE TOO EFFORTS TO GIVE FEEDBACK ON THE PROMO OF DOSTANA, YET THE BLOG DOES NOT SAY THANKS OR EVEN YOUR REACTIONS TO THE FEEDBACK YOU GOT FROM YOUR FANS

WHAT WAS INTRESTING IS IN YOUR LATEST POSTING, YOU SPEAK OF RANBIR, RISHI, RGV,IMRAN,ETC ETC BUT NOT OF SRK, NOT EVEN IN PASSING COMMENTS, THAT IS REFRESHING CHANGE

WHEN DOES KHAN ROLL ? WHEN DO PROMOS START OF DOSTANA ? WHEN DOES WAKE UP SID ROLL ? WHEN DOES SAIF -KAREENA - VIVEK MOVIE ROLLS ?

GLAD TO KNOW YOU LIKED ROCK ON, LOOKING FORWARD TO ''DIFFRENT'' MOVIES FROM DHARMA PRODUCTIONS TOO, ALL THE BEST FOR YOUR NEW PROJECTS, ALSO KOTCHIE KOTCHIE HOTHA HAI

TAKE CARE

B R MANOJ GROVER
Sunday, August 31, 2008 6:58:39 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hello Mr Karan Johar it is nice to hear from you again and to listen in on your latest about the film industry.
I have to say that i to have seen the lack of films that have gone out well this year, appart from a rising few.

Jodhaa-Akbar what can i say? The historic era films are making there way back pleasantly. I had hesitated watching it at first as the length of the film dawned uopn me since i had been quite busy with other things occuring in the earlier months, however reading in on the plot of the story had me keen and knowing Ashutosh's earlier great works on old era, what stood out the most for me was the immense chemistry between the two characters, the talented A.R Rahman again produces the finest pieces of musical composition which blends in well with the story.

Moving on another film that I had found suprisingly interesting was Race you had not mentioned it supposedly because you might have disliked it or had not seen it, the fact that it gave quite a few twists and turns had me engaged. I find Saif a great talent and needs to do films that show it off, such examples like: Kal Ho Na Ho, Hum Tum and Omkara.

Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na, that line had me singing many times. Again the music being scored by A.R Rahman, the fresh tunes that remind me of my current college days. When watching the film I fully understood the purpose, Abbas had done well to create a film that showed a different spark to the other contemporary films. I feel that both Imran and Genelia had been perfect for their roles, Jai the pacifist and Aditi the quick-tempered. I hope that Genelia chooses the right path for herself as she holds a lot of talent within. I also agree the Imran proves to have natural abilities of his own kind most definitely a watchable actor I look foward to see his follow-up i.e Kidnap in october opposite Mr Sanjay Dutt, the plot about boy versus man. And after watching the promos seeing Imran in a totally different contrast to his pervious role, will turn out to be interesting.

Those have been by far my favourite films of the year, being all different genres yet attractive in their own ways.
I have not see Rock On yet but after listening to your review I will be sure to catch it soon enough. Wondered if you have seen the recent release Mumbai Meri Jaan? As it has said to be a compelling story.

I would also like to mention YashRaj film Bachna Ae Haseeno, being keen on the first part of the movie, that somehow the second part had lacked for me. Knowing that Ranbir Kapoor shows the talent that has layed in the Kapoor family generation, years to come he will show his finest work and contribution to the film industry.

Looking forward to the next flicks of 2008 which include: Dostana, Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi, Ghajini, Kidnap, Chandni Chowk To China. And later on My Name Is Khan (most definitely).

So best wishes for the fraternity to shine over the last few months of this year, and for Dharma Production's next film Dostana I will have my ticket ready in November.

Love and always drinking Koffee, and watching Karan
God Bless,
Alvida




Filipa
Sunday, August 31, 2008 7:28:12 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hello karan sir
good to read your review for the movies of 2008 you haven't mentioned SARKAR RAJ you saw the movie or not and tell u which forthcoming movie interest you most...? I have some good stories to make movie on how can i tell you those stories please tell....best of luck for DOSTANA hope it rocks.
DO TAKE GOOD CARE OF YOURELF
GOD BLESS YOU
ankit
Sunday, August 31, 2008 7:44:40 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
HI Karan,

Yes Rock On is the movie which is looking very promising becoz of :-
1. Story

2. Look

3. Farhan Actor

Farhan has kept good standards. And I expect him to raise the bar this time too.

But you are my most favourite filmmaker of the recent times :-

1. You know what the audience wants.

2. You understand human emotions well and use them very effectively.

3. Your movies always have good music.

4. You put all the masala in the right quantities.

5. You are intelligent.

6. Last but not the least, SRK's wonder works the best for you.
Sunday, August 31, 2008 7:45:03 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan, yes im the first one to comment !!!
Shahzeb
Sunday, August 31, 2008 7:45:40 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
HEY KARAN
Shahzeb
Sunday, August 31, 2008 8:15:31 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan.....

been quite a long time since i read ur blog......but you are very true when you say that the movies this year havent been quite appealing and were a major disappointment.......i quite like rahul bose as an actor but his latest in the block "MAAN GAYE Mughale Azam" was a real headach....The latest this week K company .....cant say anything about it more than just this that half the viewers who came in for the movie were happy spending their time out at the food area rather than sit and watch the movie in(this is during the intermission).......i sometimes feel that the amount Ms Kapoor has spend trying to promote her brother if she would have used it for good causes it would have brought smiles to some section of the deprived(just a thought)

Rock On was v good..........and Farhan has definitely proved that he can act v well indeed......we dont doubt his talent as a director.....

and Phoonk as we all know is another RGV disaster....i lately heard Mr Verma claiming that anyone who can watch the movie alone wld be rewarded by him...it should be anyone who can tolerate the movie for three hours(or whtever the duration is) should be rewarded.........

anyways thats how life is......you improve and learn everyday......

when you think
life has come to an end
do not stop
there is some message hidden
which God might have just send
(so keep moving)

take care
abhilasha
Sunday, August 31, 2008 8:25:03 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hey karan
Shahzeb
Sunday, August 31, 2008 8:28:40 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan,

we have read your thoughts on JA, JTYJN etc. , but i would love to know your opinion about U, Me Aur Hum.

Bye
Meltem
Sunday, August 31, 2008 8:46:39 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,
This is my 1st rply to ur blog, so i hav to say dat am a biiiiiiiiiiiig fan of urs n the movies which u make, n obviously srk...
I lovd KWK, n hopg to c u in small screen soon..but i knw its nt possible nw 4 u as u r busy wid MNIK(desperatly waitg 4 it)...
now comg to the blog...i compltly agree wid u, i too likd jodha-akbar..
n karan who said u dont luk young??? u r very handsome karan..trust me..but i dont think there is any need 4 u to keep quite on ppl(rgv) who talk negative abt u n comment on u 4 no reason..plz go n watch phoonk n plz tell us d good qualities(if any) which it hav....
am waitg 4 ur next blog....
n thanx 4 openg this blog.....
lov u..
keep rockg...
byeeee
Sunday, August 31, 2008 10:15:42 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Did you get a chance to see Aamir? I think it was brilliant.
Sunday, August 31, 2008 11:10:31 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan!!!
I understand your feelings. But, being a great fan of your movies, I can't help talking about "My Name is Khan". Though it's different that I am bit disappointed that you guys are not shooting in New York. However, I couldn't have asked for more...SRK, Kajol, and Karan...wow.....I don't know about others..For me, this will be the biggest release of 2009.
Very often I have noticed one thing. You often understimate yourself when you are comparing yourself with other top directors. You don't need to be as you are right there. By the way you have given us Kuch Kuch hota hai ...perhaps the finest movie of all time along with DDLJ...

So, be calm. Enjoy your acheivements and do your best for the upcoming films.

Love you...
A Nepalese-American fan
Bikal Gurung
Sunday, August 31, 2008 11:51:18 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

There is no doubt that many of us look up to the way SRK carries himself. Many love him, follow him. So please tell him not to get involved in spats and attract negative publicity.

Love to you Karan and to SRK and Farah.
Love to all the readers and of course to RGV :P
Thanks,
GenusZeus.
GenusZeus
Monday, September 01, 2008 12:06:22 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan...
am really happy that Iam the first one to comment on ur recent post.
Well u hav mentioned da movies u hav lykd bt dont u feel u,me aur hum needs a mention. Though nt a gr8 film(very slow) it still has kajol and that is what makes it special for me. Newayz it is my point of view.
U hav mentioned that u receive quite a lot of questions abt ur next film.. well Iam one of them. Ur movie is eagerly awaited and thats why v all keep u askn questions... Vaise what v hav heard abt the cast frm da gossip columns of newspaprs... must congratulate u if u hav got shabana azmi on board fot srk's mother.. we all knw she is a gr8 actress and would b actualy very nice to c sum1 playn srk's mom other than farida jalal nd jaya bachchan. Talkin of farida jalal I was seeing k3g the other day(she was really gud wen she meets hrithik in london) and I realised that she was nt seen in ur last two seems... Ofcourse, There wud hav baeen no role for for bt I wud lyk 2 c her again in ur films with srk. And yes karan plzzz dont let kajol go away this time... I mean am dyn 2 wtch srk and her again.
Well karan u mentioned rgv's phoonk... It is actualy an above average kinda film and yes it entertains u lyk hell... I mean instead of gettn scared u get amusd... And Rock ON!!! simply rocks and its a really nice film.. Farhan shud tak up actn criously...
Rest I wud say plz try 2 write up posts in the blog daily.. Its really nice 2 hear frm u...
Rahul
Monday, September 01, 2008 12:07:32 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Yea this year has pretty much been an all time low for Hindi cinema...

my rankings would go something like this (from the movies Ive bothered to watch)

---BEST >>> | Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na |
---VERY GOOD >>> | Thoda Pyaar Thoda Magic | Bachna Ae Haseeno | Rock On |
---GOOD >>> | Kismat Konnection | Race | Singh Is Kinng | De Taali |
---ABOVE AVERAGE >>> | Jannat | Love Story 2050 | U Me Aur Hum |
---AVERAGE >>> | Woodstock Villa | Ugly Aur Pagli |
---BELOW AVERAGE >>> | Tashan |
---CRAP >>> | Sunday |
---UNSURE >>> | Jodha Akbar |

Stars of the year...acc to me.. have been Imran Khan, Ranbir Kapoor, Akshay Kumar,Shahid Kapoor, Genelia & Farhan Akhtar... Saif, Katrina & Bipasha did well this yr too.
Monday, September 01, 2008 12:11:51 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
There is nobody better than you to make comments so successful, your vast experience and successes are your great support, Jodha Akbar I think was a movie interesting, bollywood should release more films of this type for whom we are something far away know more about the history of India and it was good to see Hrithik in a film very different from the another previous ...
Across the world there are fans like me crazy for see "My Name is Khan" sure will be a success because only you and Shahrukh are able to create magic

Blessings

Mari
LIMA-PERU
Monday, September 01, 2008 12:42:10 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hello karan.

im a fan of all your films from kkhh.
please let me act in one of your films.i know you get these alot
but please consider me!im special!hehe
anyway thank u for readin this.

ur biggest fan
D
Dash Pather
Monday, September 01, 2008 1:31:09 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hey karan,
kudos!!.,,..,im ur boggest fan of u in dis world.,.,.,.
not actually u,..,but UR CINEMA.,,..,they r BEST,..,
n d whole bollywood sleeps eats drinks around it.,.,
hmmm.,.,
didnt u lyk RACE,.,.(personally i did n think its among biggest hits of year too),..,.,n wat u think of SINGH IS KING??
chaitanya patel
Monday, September 01, 2008 2:36:35 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
i AGREE TO WHAT YOU SAY but you must watch mithya it was a very good movie and rockon is the by far the best movie of the year
i hope i will get a reply for this ,honestly karan isnt dostaana ( im shocked you dropped k but its koooool) a ripp offf of i now pronounce you chuck and larry and i dont blame you as we do not have many writers and original scripts but i m offering you a story( for the record im the best writer in india ) which will be indias first disaster movie and only you can make it as you have the resources and monety for it---------India's first disaster movie ----- i have not written it yet i have a thought let me share it with you--
It is the story of Gunveen Chopra a little 8 year old kid ( he is a genius ) and his dad abhishekh chopra who fight with aliens to save india from aliens who have made their workshop for replacing the genes of young india with their genes and they hatch a plan to capture india ( they make these workshops in Delhi Public Schools across india) so that they can eventually capture america , just imagine Akshay Kumar or srk saving India from aliens( a lot of research is required to complete this story)..

This is just a sample i have so many stories which are ready to be told but all i need is a chance ( iwant to join you as an assistant ,i will work for free , i dont need money ,i know eventually it will come but the truth is that this is the only thing i know i can be the the best at but i have never ever seen a film set ,my only experience is watching the movies that i watch everyday and i was also a contestant of Bollywood Ka Boss on filmy channel) and please if you read this reply to me at nj_rks@yahoo.co.in
NAVJOTT
Monday, September 01, 2008 2:41:43 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
HI
NAVJOTT
Monday, September 01, 2008 2:48:30 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan sir,

this is my very 1st time on ur blog.
&
1st of all honestly i understand english little bit or more than it little more & i thought before reading ur post as well as passing a comment to add something 1st to make u impressed but later i got fortunatly that ''let leave it akash,tujhe chance nahiiiiiiiiii milega''now u vl get all.''but forget all n get true n very very 1st reply of mine 4 u,honestly'' !


-was gud,....................honestly after getting all i got that u r doing the same work that u have given throuh blog (i think so) this time i.e. as a director n all urself u this time also u enjoied,evaluate films n most important u got something new as usual,i thimk that is happened.trust me,it was really gud !




next time i vl try 2 give again more realistic response 2 u (happy !)

c u next time ,

bye !

AKASH
AKASH PRATAPSINGH RAJPUT
Monday, September 01, 2008 7:25:33 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan.

Please can you confirm when you intend to start shooting MNIK, initially i read that it will start in November 2008, but recently i read that it will start in February 2009(White House permission and all).
also the release date, is it still November 2009.
Thanks
Abdul Habib
Monday, September 01, 2008 8:31:56 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
HI karan
I absolutely love reading your posts! Keep posting regulary. You are right, as a cine-goer I think bollywood movies are becoming WAY TOO cliched and boring!! I want someone to come up with something interesting, like you always do.

I can't wait to see my name is khan, becuase I believe you can only rely on shahrukh khan movies for being good and worth going to the theater. As you can see, I'm a HUGE shahrukh khan fan:)
Take care!
shivani
Monday, September 01, 2008 8:50:45 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
ah......so i finally get to write 1st on ur blog this time....yippe...lol...

helloz and how are you?

well....i agree with you some people really performed far far better

then wat was expected and the ones who hve had done really

well in past came up with only avg. performance.

since you mentioned the best ones i would like to mention the ones

who can get better like before.


Priyanka chopra- after DON i think she could have done better, with special reference to God Tussi Great Ho.

Rani Mukarji - Thoda Pyar Thoda Magic , TaRa RumPum, not this after super performance in BLACK .

Maduhri - Aja Nachle- not after Dil Toh Pagal Hai.

With a sudden re-call I would like to mention ritesh deshmukh and shahid kapoor. both of them performed 10/10. ritesh came un-expected for me. now i do notice wat he is coming up with in his films or performance. shahid rocked the screen with jab we met.

i think kareena's performance in jab we met was over rated. I like kareena other wise.

Singh is King was an over rated film and i think so was bachna aae haseeno. but akshay's performance in sing is king and deepika & ranbir's performance in Bachna aae haseeno was again commendable.

Deepika took us all by surprise!!!


My. fav. movies of 2007-08: Namaste London, Tare Zamen Par,
Jhoom barabr Jhoom, chak de India! , Jab We Met.

well....thats what i wanted to say.....
anyways....i also want to know your where bouts...lol....are u in US or india.

take care....
lots of luv....
sumali
4m Lndn.
sumali
Monday, September 01, 2008 10:03:35 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan,

hows the my name is khan prep going? im sure its going great and youre making another masterpiece.
have you seen singh is kinng? I have not yet, but apparently its been doing really well in india and the US.
Jodhaa Akbar was AMAZING. hrithik roshan is my favorite and he was just so incredible in it. i felt like i was watching akbar, not a muscled hunk!
also, jtyjn was amazingly really really good. it just goes to show the power of the story / script.
hope to hear from you soon!
Jasmine
California, USA ;)
Jasmine
Monday, September 01, 2008 10:13:05 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan, I thought you liked Sarkar Raj too...........I remember Mr. Bachchan stating on his blog that you were with him at the premeire and really liked the movie and his performance in it............Did you miss that out ......or was it an omission because the movie was directed bt RGV......
harshita sharma
Monday, September 01, 2008 11:04:30 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan,
Reading ur blog again after such a long time was as refreshing as s finely brewed coffee... i'm sure u know what i mean :) anyway, it is good to hear from u again, as always :)
i'm so glad u too liked Rock On... After watching Jane Tu Ya Jane Na, a fresh outa-the-bakery-stock, i was hoping against hopes if the genre of these "different" movies would fade into the oblivion or not. Rock On juz simply rocked!! Kudos to all the guys for the good work done. I wanted to know if you watched Mumbai Meri Jaan or not... if u have, plz post ur comment for the same.
You post regarding RGV's Phoonk was rib-ticklingly funny. Must say, you need a thumping on your back for making the wise decision of not watching the movie. Trust you me, I'm saying it only after having watched that movie which induced some giggles out of me but the "elusive" gooseflesh still decided to stay away...
I'm really looking forward to Dostana... i wish you all the very best for this movie. Lets work the magic of KKHH again!
:)
God Bless
Luv ya
Aastha
Monday, September 01, 2008 12:33:15 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

You forgot to mention two wonderful movies that came out this year -Race and Kismat konnection.

vidya
Monday, September 01, 2008 3:44:27 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

I agree with your choice of films, that's basically what I liked too. Jodhaa-Akbar was beautiful! For some reason I did not feel excited enough about Bachna ae Haseeno. Haven't seen it yet. Saw Rock On today, it is worth watching but does not hold repeat value for me. Farhan Akhtar is a good actor, and I'm sure he must have added his own creative inputs in the film, I just can't give all the credit to Abhishek Kapoor! The Hrithik-Aishwarya chemistry is a delight! It's like SRK-Kajol. I feel Imran Khan will be a bigger actor/star than Ranbir. Having parents who are fantastic actors does not make you automatically great. Abhishek is not even half as good as Amitabh-Jaya. Only Sanjay Dutt has totally lived upto both his parents' name. The films I am looking forward to in 2008: Kidnap, Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi, Ghajini, Fashion, Billo Barber. Not sure if I will be able to watch Dostana when it comes out. My group is not too keen on watching Priyanka C, she's shown some very poor judgement in selecting her last few films (2050, chamku etc) and I certainly will not go alone! So Yuvraaj, Chandni chowk etc will have to wait till they are out on DVD or something.
Rohini Singh
Monday, September 01, 2008 3:57:21 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I like Ashutosh Gowariker, though I prefer other directors. I wonder why people complain about the pace/length of J-A, I couldn't get enough of it. It's a HISTORICAL! It will be weird if it is only 2 hrs! He had to take his own time to 'develop' the romance between H-A, the story demanded it, that's the right pace. Infact I felt there were some gaps in the direction. He needed to make it flow more realistically.
Rohini Singh
Monday, September 01, 2008 4:48:19 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi
vicky
Monday, September 01, 2008 5:51:45 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan
pls give me 29 mins of your precious time for my script narration, its a beautiful love story ...trust me it will be thye best and the grandest love story ever told.

thanks
rahuul khanna -
(vice president - karrnik productions pvt ltd)
rahuul khanna
Monday, September 01, 2008 6:45:25 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,
This post was about Hindi cinema and I'm not sure why you (and the hindi cinema industry) like calling it Indian cinema.I definitely don't want to discuss Hindi cinema vs regional cinema as both have their own merits and demerits.But I sincerely hope you would understand that hindi cinema does not represent Indian cinema.

ranjani
ranjani
Monday, September 01, 2008 7:04:04 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
i love u,me aur hum
u,me aur hum is awesome!!
kajol's performance is amazing!

Kajol and Ajay make a superb pair and ajay is a very good director!
suzan
Monday, September 01, 2008 7:38:01 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I am little bit surprised that you havent mentioned any thing abt U Me Aur Hum and Ajay as the first time director and Kajay's performance in UMAH...

Don't you think she is much better than Ash?

You didnt like a bit of it...???
Naani
Monday, September 01, 2008 7:49:47 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey karan this is my second post and wud lyk to knw what do u thnk about U,Me aur hum. I actualy thought it ws a pretty decent film and ajay devgan had done a fine job as a director. Though I feel that it ws extremely slow and cud hav had more romantic feel to it. Newayz this ws my point of view.

Another film of which evry1 is talkn about is singh is kingh. I wud luv to knw how did u lyk the film(if u hav seen). I feel it ws a complete entertainer.. ofcourse it had no story.. bt i thnk most of the comedy films in India shud b watchd keeping our brains at home.. nd u cn njoy evry bit of it then... Katrina lukd fab and yes she deserves a place in ur production house as she has that class whch need 2 b there in a karan johar actress.

Talkn of Bachna ae haseeno.. again I feel that the movie got appreciation, more than what it actually deservd. The second half of the movie(specially interaction b/w kunal kpoor and ranbir) mak it luk bore. and the movie seems to lose its pace. I found the film lengthy. Ofcourse Ranbir,Minisha and Bipasha were awesum. I think kudos 2 minisha who stands out in the presence of bips and deepika(she had nutn great to do in the film)

Lastly, ROCK ON!!!! Now this is what v call a really nice film. Gud direction and gud actn. Farhan is great as an actor. The music roxxx(though sum mite find da lyrics a bit weird). I think compared to the recent lot of films which released(phoonk,Singh is king,BAH) this one stands tall with the most sensible story. Only thing I feel which cud hav been better wud b da dialogues.

And yes mumbai meri jaan is also a very nice film though it goes a bit born after da interval. The film has sum really nice acting by Paresh Rawal and soha ali khan. The film shows the real spirit of mumbai people. But Irrfan Khan's story is sumthn I feel was realy stupid.

Rest plz write ur posts regularly...
Rahul
Monday, September 01, 2008 9:47:34 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Thats HYPOCRISY at its best Karan...You like one kind of films and you make another kind!!!

Would you DARE make any of the 3 films you liked this year????

btw...you forgot a certain Mr. King (pun unintended) Kumar's biggest HIT of the year in your list!!!!...After all he is current No.1 in Bollywood...is it not Karan?? ;)
RGV
Monday, September 01, 2008 9:49:22 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
ah yes this year was far from the best Hindi cinema has seen, but we're still waiting for some releases- those in which Shahrukh will star :D the year is not over yet
botox? i seriously doubt u'd need any of that!
looking forward to your upcoming entries :) best of luck
Dea
Monday, September 01, 2008 10:32:22 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
karan
Why didnt u mention U me aur hum. kajol was really good in the film. No two ways that u present her in a best way but plz mention kajol for u me aur hum she was really good
Shanky Mahajan
Monday, September 01, 2008 11:15:12 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

Didn't you like Shahid Kapur in Kismat Konnection? I think he was absolutely wonderful in that...

What do you say? By the way, your blogs are written very beautifully, covering all the aspects of all the films and your comments are very genuine... Thanks for these blogs and I hope we will get to know more of you through your writing.... Just one question, do you reply to the comments posted in reply to your blogs..

Take care and keep up the good work :)

Monika
Monika
Monday, September 01, 2008 11:26:33 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan,
Just wanted to ask you when are you coming to London for a shoot? We hardly get any news here?

Do let your London fans know about the good news that you will be shooting in London as well....

We wish you all the best for all your future projects and wish you all the very best in whatever you do..

God bless :)
Monika
Monika
Monday, September 01, 2008 11:37:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
now plz plz plz do cast imran khan in your next film starting with "k"..hehehe....i can be his co star , i really dont mind :P


luv
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 3:45:00 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan, i have been a constant reader of your blog since the first update. May Allah b with u in each second of every minutes. We love so much in Nigeria.
Olusesi Usman
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 7:26:42 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
what bout films like shaurya, race and bachna ae haseeno? who are the rest of the cast of your film other than srk and kajol?
alamin rashid
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 8:25:54 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,
You are so right about all the movies that released this year. I also enjoyed JTYJN and Rock on is simply superb.Also enjoyed BAH and Race. Sing is King was over-rated but akshay was awesome in it. RGV's phoonk was more of a comedy than horror movie.Nothing was scary.Good that you didn't watch it. Looking forward to Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi and of course MNIK. I'm sure it will be a superb movie that will break all records.
Wishing you good health and all the success.
Take care.
Bye.
polynar
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 8:57:30 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I agree with you that 2008 has not been one of the promising years for bollywood cineastes with the exception of the films that you mentioned in your post. This weekend I watched Rock On (before I watched "Mumbai Meri Jaan") and found it to be all gloss with no substance. I admire Farhan as a director but his singing is a different story (he needs to find a new hobby). As an actor he is fine as long as he does not open his mouth. His voice lacks the modulation that is required for the depth in dialogue delivery and is in fact very distracting (please read annoying). Now we are awaiting your latest creation "My Name is Khan"-I am certain I won't be disappointed. I know I'll watch it just for Kajol as it is such a treat to watch Kajol on screen especially when she performs with SRK. Looking forward to it!
TC,
Monica
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:35:56 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan Sir,

The trailer looks good!
....my honest feedback would be the KHNH music and your previous achievents take up a longer duration that the teaser itself

....you want to grab our attention with jump-cut scenes and add in your credentials in.

....let's face it, many of us, myself included, have short-attention spans.

....the "hum GAY hain" would be funnier from Abhi as his facial expressions are more comical.

.....as it's tough to pass John as GAY as his image is more of a sporty dude

.....have an insanely-funny dialogue that people (especially guys)mimic to their friends and adds to the anticipation to have it release. "Hum GAY hain" just doesn't cut it.

.....the musical score needs a catcher track than "bounce'

......put some more slapstick sophomoric humor that gets the audience in giggles so that transference gets them in a good movie to see the film

.....showing the push-tug chemistry between the guys...for the girl...."garam masala" style...especially when experimenting with a new pair (especially guy-bonding like in any classic hero-sidekick cop flick)

...Priyanka looks like a mere prop in the film (she wouldn't be my 1st choice in casting) so give her a dialogue in the trailer that may give the audience a reason why the guys like her besides her hot body. That's how Janemaan went wrong.

.......why do I even bother to take the time to tell you this?....I'm an Internation Film & Media Studies Major:concentration in Production so I'm not just talking out of my butt

...I hope my suggestions add a new vantage point if you are surrounded by bobble heads who agree with you on everything.

.....I'll be graduating in December Loyola University-Chicago, and will be on the career market. If you feel that I would be a good addition to Dharma Productions, feel free to contact me or even if you might want my feedback on other aspects of this or the SRK film!

....You already got lady luck so I'm going to wish you patience as you finish up post-production!
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:39:42 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
thank so much pfor you message I am honored to be here in your blog, for me is a great pleasure to know that you have the strong will and affection to respond to all your fans and what really makes a great person, besides his admirable work in films and his life, to obtain large satisfy already given us the feeling that many fans and we recognize that a great man thanks again with affection and respect for paola a Chilean fans across the world
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:50:09 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)

I am honored to be here in your blog, for me is a great pleasure to know that you have the strong will and affection to respond to all your fans and what really makes a great person, besides his admirable work in films and his life, to obtain large satisfy already given us the feeling that many fans and we recognize that a great man thanks again with affection and respect for paola a Chilean fans across the world
besides being a great director, he was esperal of having the same success as my name is KHAN use of films has learned a lot here in your country and traditions and it would be very gratifying to see more so with his great experience gained a travez the years makes his players feel proud of their films and the people of their land
Paola
arica_chile
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 10:52:13 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
dear karan,
I feel that you are a versatile person why dont you make a movie on real story if you want a story i can help you in that just in case you begin to think about it contact me on my id
purnish88@yahoo.com

all the best for your great future ahead .
one more thing give chance to some unpromising new comers also they may also click with you.
purnish
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 11:08:30 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
i agree with you karan but i just wanted to ask you that didn't you like u me aur hum????and kajol's performance in it???
pavitra
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 12:26:50 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
RESPECTED KARAN
MY NEWS ARE NOT BEING AIRED AND I DONT KNOW WHY
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 1:03:07 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
'Rock On' is technically brilliant. The way it enters into the song 'Yeh tumhari meri baatein' just makes the film worth watching multiple times. And the best part is that the film has many such moments. Indeed a perfectly executed simple script.

'Mumbai Meri Jaan' is also worth mentioning. Its script is excellent and it was taken to another level by the actors. Although inspired by a hollywood movie, 'Shourya' was exceptional too. KK Menon surely deserves an award this year, he is a phenomenon.

Jodha Akbar was tolerable just because of the drama, Rehman's music and Hrithik's acting. Ashutosh Gowarikar does not need to prove himself (after Swades). But he had such a nice opportunity to make an unforgettable film and he could not grab it. I think the film was justifiably long but he could not give justice to each and every scene in it, may be because of lack of time (He clearly needed a better assistant).

Ranbir Kapoor has an awesome timing and confidence. I did not expect anything from 'Bachna Ae Haseeno', however 'mere dollars wasool ho gaye' because of the title song and Ranbir's performance.

'Jaane Tu..' was simple and enjoyable. However, it did not have any memorable factors except the music. Title track (female version) and the jazz are outstanding. By the way, do you ever plan to work with AR Rehman?

Looking forward to Shahrukh's Item number in Dostana and the album (but not the movie, I cannot tolerate Abhishek).

-Pankaj
Pankaj
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 2:26:02 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Jodhaa Akbar - Very pure and refined. Exceptional detailing and measured performances. Loved the length of the film and Rahman's music.

Jaane Tu - Fresh, fresh, fresh.

Rock On - Breathtakingly shot and brilliantly edited. Makes for an interesting narrative.

You didnt mention about Mumbai meri jaan. I think it was excellent and qualifies as one of the finest films to have happened this year.

Phoonk & Sarkar Raj were typical RGV fares and pretty mediocre.

Race was quite good. Racy, with a million hair-pins.

But I think Drona and the others should be good. Looking forward to Khan from you. Hope it is devioid of the usual melodrama which I hate.
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 2:40:47 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I forgot to add one thing...

I'm not sure whether you're done the casting of My Name is Khan but I REALLY, REALLY, REALLY hope you add some exciting names to the list...maybe a few that you wouldn't normally? India's got some amazing actors, but they never get a chance to shine. There's about 15-20 stars that hog all the limelight even though they may not be the best actors. (Cough cough...Katrina Kaif...sorry if you like her LOL!)
Aly K...again!
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 3:07:57 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,
This is my first time here and you have got a cool blog...nice,sweet and not much content oriented..just like your films :).

Hope RGV wud be generous enough like you and wish you for your next weepy hit...all the best...and yup my name starts with a K,any casting chances there :)
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 4:31:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)

Please cast Hrithik-Ash in a movie directed by YOU not your protege. What Chemistry!!!!!!


You could do a Silsila version with Abhisek in it too.
Star
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 4:32:50 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)


Eagerly awaiting DOSTANA.

Pls read Big B's blog. Awsome.

HE IS THE GOD OF ACTING.
Star
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 4:34:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)


Please direct Aamir, Ash, Akshay and Sanjay in your style.
Star
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 4:37:20 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)


Loved Jodha Akbar, Sarkar Raaj but Singh is King and Race were fine too.

Most people go to watch stars not newcomers. How many teeny bopper movies can one watch in a year??
Star
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 5:47:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan.
you love jaane tu ya jaane na?i think this movei is completly like yours kkhh what do you think?but i love that
i love thoda pyaar thoda magic too.it was sooo nice.
but still the best movie is kank.i love love love it for ever
im sure my name is khan cant be like that.and im realy looking forward for dostana.All the best for you
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 7:16:31 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan,

Really awaiting for your movie DOSTANA....looking damn cool....dont be kanjoos in divulging details about the movie My name is Khan...as whatever may be the movie m gonna watch in theatre.

As I am ardent fan of your movie....I even watched KANK 5 times in theatre.

I liked it....will always.

I agree that Rock On is the best movie ahead.

Regard,

Priya
Priya Singh
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 8:13:21 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

Glad to see your blogg.....it had been more then two weeks and I was getting a little worried that you of all people had nothing say....hahaha

Anyways, I was happy to ready that you also felt that this year has been so poor for Bollywood movies. I am also suprised at some of this years hits.

If we are going to celebrate movie like Welcome and Sing is King becoming a super hit ...then I feel really sad for our ferternity. It has helped that a power house like Yash Raj couldn't deliver us anything concrete after Chake De.

Yes movies like Rock On and Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na are fresh and more apealing to the younger generation and although I haven;t seen either of these movie..I just feel we has an Industry are desperate and are clutching to anything. Scripts..scripts and even more quality scripts..we need some good stories and some decent directors to put them on cellaloide.

You are right that the next 4 months have some good movies planned for release but lets face it.....if we didn;t have film makers like your self and Yash Raj...I would not watch Hindi Movies.

You had mentioned that your favourite star has been Rishi all this time. You have also mentioned that you would also love to work with Neetu....but here your chance. Lets get the wheels of Dhrma working on a script where all three of them(Rishi, Neetu and Ranbir) would come together and create magic for not only Bollywood but for Dharma as well.

I also saw your pics in the latest copy of Filmfare,,and I liked them alot. It was nice to see something done on a director...you must be the only Director in town that filmfare or any other magazine must have done a article on.

I think it;s time for you to do an iterviews in filmfare and inform everyone of you company;s plan ..your up and comming movies so everyone one knows that Dharam means bussiness and will be in the power list very soon. Updating your website and informing everyone there will also address your fans but doing iterviews takes care of others who are not familiar with your work.

On a more humorus note, I think your Mum must have been really proud of your photos in Filmfare..as this will mean having calls from some decent Punjabi Familes asking for your Rishta.

On a sepreate topic..I dont think you should waste anymore time on Mr Verma...his kind of Cinema belong to him and we will stick to what we are good at.It;s funny in a old interviews he aparently has a daugter that he keeps very hush hush about and he was angry or disapponted at her as she doesn't like her dad's movies but will be the first one to go and see a Kjo movie...thats so funny......

You are right you can't write too much about My Name is Khan...I think we as your fans are just too excited about the whole affair.

Music music music..what are you currently listening to and what have been this years favourite hindi Albums.

I would alos like to know whats invloved in a typical Kjo day.

How was recent trip to the states for some pre production work on My name Is Khan...were you able to get the locals that you wanted.

Anyways, keep on blogging....don;t leave it too late like last time

Tony

tony
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 8:17:57 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan,
There is no dbout that you are an excellent film maker. Every film of DHARMA PRODUCTIONS is one of the best films in India. Atleast they are very good than Yash Raj Films. Karan, I am noting from the last few years when I see your films that the characters and the songs and music is very lovely. Once the people listen them they become the fan of that film. Since I have never posted any comment but after reading your blog I seriously felt one thing that:
EAST OR WEST KARAN JOHAR IS THE BEST
I am really feeling proud to be associated with you through your blog and wants to continue my association with you.

Wishing you all the success
Anuj Dhingra
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 9:37:26 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan...

I agree with ya... Ranbir is going to be a huge star/superstar... No two ways about that... He simply rocked in BAH...
Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na is one of the surprising film of this year... Both Genelia and Imran gave superlative performance... Indeed they deserve best new comer award and they are gonna sweep all the awards...!!

Moving on to Hrithik-Ash I agree that they gave awesome performance and the film itself was F-A-N-T-A-S-T-I-C...!!

But C'mon yaar.. How could you ever forget and not mention the awesome and never seen chemistry of Kajol-Ajay in U ME AUR HUM? And for that matter, the non-surprising and yet flawless performance of your favourite actress-Kajol...?? In my opinion, although the film is recieved as an average film, her performance is equally better if not much much better than Ash's performance, who is the only competitor this year... And by the way the film has got awesome reviews and may be you are the one of the few critic who havent liked the film, if I am right.. since you have mentioned that you talk about only what you like....

p.s. I am a fan of Kajol and I was really awaiting to hear ure take on UMAH and Kajol's performance (since you do talk abt her every performance) in one of ure interview or in one of ure blog... But alas.. You have dissapointed me by not mentioning any thing...:( :(
Azza
Tuesday, September 02, 2008 11:19:03 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
What about Sarkarraj, you praised the film? Was it to impress Big B?
sreekanth
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 12:40:39 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
kajol's performance in u,me aur hum is very good , she is much better than Ash...u,me aur hum is a great movie and i dont know why the movie did average business in india!!
u,me aur hum is awesome movie , even much better than Jane Tu Ya Jane Na
nikol
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 2:12:06 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

I think one of the best works of Ashutosh's was Swades. A movie that was not appreciated by the maases but was technically brilliant. The script was witty yet light.

Srk proved once again why he works only with the best. Lagan came close second but this movie was urban yet rural. Srk's chemistry with the new girl Gyhatri was also excellent.

Jodha on the other hand was a definate NO..NO for me after a master peice like swades.

I know you like both Ashitosh and Sanjays work...but Sanjays Sawariya was a big let down....anyways, alot has been said about sawariya but then all directors need that Jolt every now and then....as Kank was for Dharma Productions.

Lets not leave Yash Raj productions although they used new directors but they both Yash Uncle and Aditia are the brains behind the scripts and all the techinical productions work. However, this past year has also proved for them that only good scripts make good movies.

Rakesh Roshan...let see... he likes to copy scripts..nothing is too orginal but his strong points are Hrithik and great music. Even with a week script he has pulled his movie through. His early work before his son was introduced wasn't that good or appealing but I have always said that he has the same kind of music sense as yourself and Yash Uncle.

Rajkumar Hirani..well what can...he is a through gentleman, seems like a guy who has a good sense of humor. He is a very talented percon...everything about this guy smells success. I think Vinod has got a real gem working for his company.

Mani Ratnam..well he has his kind if cenima and audiance that I donlt really attach to so I cant say too much about him.

Subash Ghai....another invidual who is hight talented but someone who is getting too dated for the times. He knows everything about film making but somewhere lacks the youth full ness in his movies. You can tell he could have really benefited from having sons who could have taken his company to greater heights. Another director who has great sense for music.

I hope you liked my take on some directors that you have also interviewed on your programe plus the filmfare article that was done on all of the directors last year.

I havent mentioed any recents promising directors as they have alot to prove.

I dont need to mention you here as you are a class above all of these directors...however, just thought i would share these thoughts with you.

Tony





tony
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 2:57:53 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
HEY KARAN,

I WANT TO SAY THAT THIS YEAR WILL BE THE GOOD YEAR FROM NOW BECAUSE THERE IS TOO MANY RELEASES IN LAST FEW MONTHS ANDTHERE ARE MANY PROJECTS JO THODA HATKE THAT WORKS ON OUR CINEMAS FRON LAST FEW YEARS I HAVE TO SAY THAT IN LAST THIS LAST MONTHS WILL MAKE MOR MONEY THAT OUR BOLLYWOOD MAKES IN 2007
TC
DEPANSHU
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 4:26:16 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan...
Kajol Kajol Kajol Kajol She is the best actress in the whole world...She is amazing actress no one can be like her...She is wonderful ...beautiful and really nice woman...Kajol is WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW..
Karan I dont Know how can I say to you thanks for bringing back magic couple ...they are really made for each othere...
lots of love ...
and Im waiting for best movie in the world My name is khan...
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 5:26:33 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I hope that you would contact me for your film my name is khan, I would like to be a part of it! I live in los angeles and you are shooting there, it would be fun to be part of a karan johar flick =) Please contact me or give me a talent agency or casting director to see for this movie, I would love to be an extra!!! =)
Saida
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 11:56:54 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)


Please direct Hrithik and Ash.
Sonya
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 4:11:45 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

ur summing up of the year was exact so far...except I can't comment on JTYJN... I did not watch that movie...'cause the stars did not look to me watchable for 3hours!!

Yes you are right about Rock On...I did not know Farhan was such a good actor...10 points to him...having said that when do we see you before the camera Mr.K Jo??!! no...no...don't give us those cameo appearance of hero's friend in DDLJ or like you did in Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna.. in the train...m sure you have that actor inside you...so unleash that...m sure it will be a role of a lifetime...like your first movie was a masterpiece..KKHH...

You just love to build up suspense on "My Name is Khan"...c'mon now..u can give us some gyan every now and then...mebbe I could contribute to the story...

Positive attitude helps...
let's hear more from you...
RISHI
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 4:19:23 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
LOVED YOUR VIEWS KARAN
BUT I THINK YOU FORGOT TO MENTION BIPASHA BASU,S PERFORMANCE I BACHNA AE HASEENOO.......
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
WE ARE WAITING FOR YOUR my name is khan.


Wednesday, September 03, 2008 6:45:19 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
WHY DIDN U MENTION U ME AUR HUM??!!! aJAY Has made quite an impressive debut as director.. N IT was such a gr8 movie..!!!
n I think Kajol's performance in the movie was much much better than any of the actreses in their movies this year.. ( a loadz better ash in jodha anyways..) !!!!!

saw dostana's trailer.. the movee lukz reallyyy gud....!!!! all de besttt
ananya
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 6:55:12 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
what?????? Y no U ME AUR HUM in ur list???????
didnt ya think it was a gud moveee???

n Pleeesee Kajol was awesome in it!! her performance ant evn be compared2 ash bachhan in jodhaa!!!

ny r u nt menitonin anytgin bout Kajol in the blog.. u knoe there are a loads of her fans whu r visitin this blog 2 get smthin bout her..!!\

hmm anyway bol 4 dostana....( john n piggy chops lukin hot bt nt abhishek!!0 :P
c yaa
sneha
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 7:56:16 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
karan please your film my name is khan only starring Shah Rukh Khan and Kajol .not rani,priety karina ,etc,...
and please make a romantic song for srkajol like suraj hua madham
i love the song forever
samir
Wednesday, September 03, 2008 10:43:55 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
nathin more but muah muah muah!!!!iv alwez loved ur muviez...n ya....k2h2...muah muah muah....
\m/ \m/
xoxoxo
riddhima
Thursday, September 04, 2008 11:50:03 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hey karan,ur views were really appropriate for each movie,,,but u forgot to mention bips in bachna.....she was just too good.....n yes wen r u going to be back with koffee with karan.i really miss that show....n wanna see it again...
esha
Thursday, September 04, 2008 12:27:29 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Interesting entry but there isn't much I can say this time. I just don't have the means to watch all these movies until long after when they come out on DVD. I did see Jodha-Akbar, it was nice, impressive in style, eminently watchable and Hrithik did surprise me agreeably, but it didn't strike me as a milestone. For all the other movies I will have to wait until they are out. But your entry has given me at least an idea what to look for.

On a totally different note:
I am really glad you linked up SRK with an actress somewhere close to his age range. His last few films were all stoked with young, unknown girls. Why do you think is that? Do actors and directors have a problem with women of a certain age? Do you think life is over once a female has hit 35?... or even earlier? Or is it more that the male actors fear age themselves and can't cope with actresses that put them closer to their natural age?
I'm myself past the dreaded 40 ;) and I don't think that our age range is anywhere near the grave. Look at Mamma Mia... the musical just out... very bollywoodesque btw in my opinion. Look at those females... sexy, strong, funny... and mostly well past 40. Oh... and the film is mostly done by females, too.

But maybe that's exactly the point? Has the a male directed world trouble accepting that women past a certain age are more than just nice trappings? That, if truth be told they put the movers and shakers on the backbench... in a very silent way?

And love doesn't end when you're past 25. There is a whole range of stories out there that never gets told because apartently people (no men) think they are either not worth telling... or the public doesn't want to see them.

So most movie goers are teens to early 20ies. Now is that because they're the ones to primarily go to the cinema... or is that because there is nothing in the cinema to appeal to an older range of viewers? What is an over 40 year old to do with a teenybopper film? Steer away from it... or watch it kicking and screaming because she was dragged by the hair by her niece.

Life isn't over when you hit 40... there are many stories worth telling... and many a great actress worth watching them.

Right... sorry bout the rant... but your l'Oréal remark set me off. BTW... I'm a bit saddened that men now too fall into the cosmetic trap. They've taken our well earned wrinkles from us... now they try to deprive the male half of them as well. When grey hair and a more rugged look can make a man so much more appealing. Puppies are cute... but maturity has a its own, strong appeal. At least for people who can see past the surface.

Yours

Thursday, September 04, 2008 12:56:45 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
U were a coke addict when young? Euh.. je crois que je dois dire "younger" because you are still young, n'est-ce pas? :p
Better not take on the habit of zero-coca then... too much aspartame in that... u might forget your fans in some years' time, so heart-breaking it would be!!! :(

M'enfin! U don't have much frown lines, do u? Why Botox? U know that's temporary-effect, right? Anyway.. get some home-made mask may be.. when you have some time...
Thinking abt it, some lines and brow furrows ain't bad either.. signs of a "thinker"! :D

Well, your post makes me realise how I am missing films.. not watching tv, film et al... pff.. sacrifiiiiiiice... Once Eid's over, I'm planning to catch up with some... better they be good! Im sooo much starved! ;)

Keep blogging! At least I'm abreast to these film-bits! Take care.. c ya!

Samiiah
Samiiah
Thursday, September 04, 2008 6:20:21 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan

i wander what about aur & your favroit kajol in u me aur hum she was ameazing in it & no one compeir her this year she did avery defecult jub &her cemestiry with ajay was ameazing 2 acushly the whule film the best movie in this year i hope kajol will wen best actor femele 4 this year

i am waiting 4 my name is khan blease tell us something about kajol roll in it

sory my E not will
Thursday, September 04, 2008 7:13:38 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hey karan i know it long time tat i dint write to u
but dear i was really busy studies u know
par i read a book "nything for u maam"" its a mast movie masala types waise even one night is par thats already bout to release


nother aditi in jaane tu was good but this is real aditi yaar
kuch bhaw to even i deserve yaar.........

chalo as of now u njoi the festivities of making the movie nd we will
of ganpati bappa.... missing koffeee with ur desi tadka

jaldi se aao
and very imp
im dying to talk to u seriously bout assisting u
to kuch ho sake to batana plz
really wana do it

hope u will reply this time
love

aditi
aditi
Thursday, September 04, 2008 10:29:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan, you are a young man and do not need Botox . ;)
I like your grey hair. It shows your life experience.
I am waiting foe Dostana, maybe I can watch it somewhere here in a German cinema. (On the Hamburg Filmfest?)
Grretings from Germany
Friday, September 05, 2008 7:28:29 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan...
Whats up???Kajol's performance in u me aur hum was really great she was really fantastic...she is such a good actress in the world and no one can be like her. She is really ALMIGHTY...
any way karan what a bout My Name Is Khan??not yet?!
Karan pleae a lot of people are Wating to see shahrukh khan and Kajol together please karan I wanne see them together...
love you Karan and hope all the best for you...
WAIT FOR MY NAME IS KHAN BEST MOVIE IN THE WORLD WITH KING & QUEEN( SRKAJOL)
Friday, September 05, 2008 9:16:45 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Awesome movie reviews Karan! :)

I'm interesting in becoming a screenwriter do you have any options for me that I could do?
Meera D
Friday, September 05, 2008 11:54:08 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Sir I really like the music of your movies especially in the movie Kabhi Khushi Kabhi Gham , keep it up
Friday, September 05, 2008 1:18:01 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan - Am surprised you didnt mention Aamir in your list. I thought the movie was a little pleasant surprise and enjoyed it thoroughly!
BZ
Friday, September 05, 2008 7:02:29 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

Great to see Dharam Productions bringing out a slew of movies within the next year or so.....and liked some of the stars in it too...however, I think you need to work on some scripts that can bring in stars like Shahid and Akshay Kumar into our camp.

I'am not talking about these two guys because they are my favorite actors....no , but they would do wonders for Dharma. I have always been a fan of your movies and the the stars you have repeated but these two stars would bring that extra something that at times might be lacking at Dharma.

I know these stars have date problems or they might not want to work at Dharma due to various resons but with your charm sir ..you can convience anybody.

I know you have mentioned in your earlier bloggs that it's really tough trying to get some big stars together as at times producers have to wait for ages....but what to do..you will not be able to chage the equation in your life time.

The other two stars that I think would be great for Dharma productions which would be really hard to get are Aamir and Hrithik...if you ever managed to get those two on board for one of your movies.....that would like having a cherry on the cake.

Anyways, I hope didn;t mind you giving some suggestions anything to take Dharma into new heights.

I bet you must have had loads of e-mails or posts on these kind of matters and I'am sure you are already aware what to do and whom to address for your next slew of movies.

A well wisher

Tony

tony
Friday, September 05, 2008 8:19:02 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
~!~!~~!~~~Karan!!~~!!~~!!~~~!~!!

I totally agree with you that Ranbir is a Rising star and he is here to do "things"... And I am sure he'd live up to the names and deeds of his father and grandfather and the entire kapoor clan.

Farhan's "Rock On" is a welcome change .... and it is Really cool...~!

And Genelia.... she's Fabulous.. the list of adjective would not suffice her abilities...She's been so from Boys to masti and to her recent Hit JTYJN......

And I am sure Imran would be te GenNext's Apna rockstar hero ...The Promo of his new movie .."kidnap" looks Promising......

I am awaiting "Dostana.." After seeeing the promo and the "chemistry" Between John n Abhishek ... I am really looking forward to it.... Priyanka Looks her usual Ravishing self in it.. apart from the Hotties (A&J) :-P LOL...

I am eagerly wanting to watch the chemistry b/w Ranbir n Konkona in "Wake Up Sid"...The Title is very Inviting ...Hope teh Movie lives upto it ..:-)

And "phoonk.."
No comments :-P

N ,karan .. I am sure U would look as fabulous as you are even without L'oreal n Botox... :-D
with Luv...

!!~!~~~~~!~~~!!~!!~~!NanDini!~~~!~!~~~~!~~!~~!~~!~!~!~~!~~~~~!~!~!
Nandini
Friday, September 05, 2008 11:28:18 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi... I read all the comments here n I to hav same opinion as many of them here.. Y didn u mention KAJOLl's performance in u me aur hum!!!!
NONE of the actresses cant be compared wit her.. she simplyy was TOOO GUD in it!!! n I hope she gets an award 4 it.. if she get a filmfare 4 it thn she'll set a record of gettin most no best actress award !!!! breakin de record of her aunt NUtan!!!

do you really read the comments here.. if u do.. thn atleast in ur nxt blog u should be mentionin abut OUR fav actress KAJOL!!!!!!

meera
Saturday, September 06, 2008 3:51:38 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi KARAN..
I know already I posed a lot of comment but Karan did you see this picture?

http://i36.tinypic.com/suwsxc.jpg

this is new picture of Kajol . OMG Karan Im krazzy for this photo its wonderful amazing she looks sooooooooooooooo beautiful OMG Karan ...PLZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ tell to Kajol she is definition of beautiful word...Karan God created kajol like an angel...
one more thing karan you are right her eyes saying us more than she said.
any way Karan what a bout My Name Is Khan??Karan I wanna see new picture of Shahrukh and Kajol...
Lots of love KARAN...
Saturday, September 06, 2008 4:29:45 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)

Hi Karan...

Happened to come across ur blog TODAY??? Gwad wud was I doing all dis time?????? Good to see u riting about different movies and People... but I would like to stick to my FAVs SRK-Kajol.... !!!! Waiting for My Name is Khan.. !!! Actually cant wait for it.. u know wat I mean.... hehe.
Do u kind of reply to comments as well???? If not, then plz do. It wud be great u know.
Lots of Love!!
Nilanjna
Saturday, September 06, 2008 7:35:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi karan why do u write a new post soooooo late.....kya bloging se bhi oobh gaye????i just love you when u say u COLOR UR HAIR TO HIDE THE GREY.....i also applaud u 4 this coz no celeb till date has been able to admit it in t open..... can simi greywal ever say this??oops!!!why r u getting depressed over ur age.....gosh u r only a young lad of 36 n u hve inherited v youthful genes which will always give u a v young look but plz stop wearing gold color jackets,velvets n shinny-shiny stuff....just wear cool causal chic wear........if u want girls to fall 4u.....00ps!!!n plz P.S stop showing gandhigiri 4 RGV.....i am sending him flowers n choco to get well 4ever........oof!oof!!
KAVITA
Saturday, September 06, 2008 7:48:50 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan,

My post is not actually a response to your blog. It's just a fan mail from Tokyo for you and your whole production team.

I'm writing this because if I'm not mistaken, "Kal ho naa ho" is being shown for the first time in Japan, along with "K3G" and I went to the screening today.

I could not believe myself when I first cried watching your movies, because I tend to look down on the mushy kind of cinema. I saw at least 3 times each of your movies and the result is always the same: I cried every time your heroine cried! Apart from yours(especially Naina, Anjali), there are very few movie heroines with whom I could really identify myself.

As I only know a dozen of words in Hindi,I'm not sure if I could say this, but your dialogue and narratives are the most touching things I've ever heard or seen in a movie.

I hope all the best for you and your entire team, and please try to bring your movies to the theaters in Japan!

Best wishes,
Mikki
Saturday, September 06, 2008 9:47:41 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey karan left a comment before but did not get approved lets try again

really nice post once again and a really nice list , like you pointed out this year has been great for indian cinema.

Seen most of those movies Jaane tu Jaane na and Joddha akbar were both films that i did not want to see at first but both were really good and glad i watched them after..for me anyways both told a good romantic story in a different way. Definetly reminds you of your college day and am sure karan you look way better now than then that you do not need to worry.

Others that you have not mentioned in Race which had great twists, U me aur hum and kismet konnection , I loved love story because i found it different and liked the small things about it and actors were really good. Akshay kumar films i am not a fan of since i do not like that genre of comedy so will stay away from that ...

Anyways i am sure that best is yet to come with your movie and rab ne banade jodi just saw the pics for that movie looks awesome. So cannot wait i think its upto you if you comment or not definetly love to know more later on am really looking foward to seeing kajol/srk again and what the story is going to be exact.....i think you are going to suprise us again.

xxx
Narinder aka nina from UK
Saturday, September 06, 2008 10:08:16 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hello Mr Johar:)

I am a huge fan of Shah Rukh Khan and I hope to see your new film as soon as possible.
And I must write something:).
Today I had a dream (like this man from Outer World Of SRK - during Temptation 2004 in USA) that I will dance with Shahrukh Khan on stage during Temptation Reloaded in Berlin.
I hope that my dream will be fullfilled:)
All the best for You and the team
Beata
Beata
Saturday, September 06, 2008 11:20:45 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
U,Me aur Hum..u didnt like it?seriously..that movie deserves alot of praise!Jodhaa Akhbar..too long!
Nash
Sunday, September 07, 2008 12:47:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Tahaan should be good too......yet to watch it
but it sounds different and fresh

jaanu tu rocked but aamir which didnt stay for long at the theatres was good too...
wait a second
how come i forgot Shaurya? the performances were good
altho it was a re-make of 'a few good men'.....but anyone who hasn't seen a few good men will like shaurya too......
Asmita
Sunday, September 07, 2008 3:42:54 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan,
totally agree with ur choice of best movies of 2008.JODHA AKBAR was simply FANTASTIC.PLEASSSSSSSSSSSSSS cast ASH and HRITHIK in a film of urs.
hey SONYA, i have been reading ur posts on karan's blog.it seems u love AISHWARYA like i do.i am crazy about her.wonder when we'l get to see ASH AND HRITHIK or ASH AND SRK IN KARAN 'S FILM.

saba
Sunday, September 07, 2008 5:03:50 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi Karan well,where r the actor- stars in present bollywood????? i c NONE,gone r the yesteryears wth natural,passionate,charming actors who were STARS....Ranbir k.....reminds of the KASHMIRI boys that come down to DELHI in winters to sell SHAWALS.....no i m not such a catty bitch but just saw a strong resemblance.......He has ZEERO APPEAL unlike his grand dad RAJ KAPOOR whose passionate lover looks could melt anyone,no class like Shami kapoor,no charisma like Shashi kapoor no cuteness like his papa RISHI whose SMILE is better than any woman......so he is just a plain guy from the hills.....IMRAN KHAN......THE ONLY GREEK GOD WAS the pakistan cricket player why even keep the same name when in looks n manner NO ONE can be imran khan ever... this one looks more frightened than innocent......n now arjun n fahran look lost in filmdon they should open up a travel agency they look well toured.......well thats it fm me more soon on our plastic.robotic tarzan type heroines soon.
KAVITA
Monday, September 08, 2008 1:06:56 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi karan. how are you?I came to this blog several times and I really enjoy of your writing.Karan Im so happy shahrukh khan and kajol are coming back together a lot of fan are waiting for my name is khan plase karan say some thing about kajol in movie plase karam say what is kajols performance in my name is khan karan SrKajol are AMAZING couple they made for each other.
thank you karan for every thnigs.
sarahjan
Monday, September 08, 2008 4:43:22 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I'm surprised you didn't mention Aamir, because it was another brilliant film. In fact I thought it was one of the most decent films this year. Very thought provoking.

The other night I was watching Kuch Kuch Hota Hain (for the nth time) my eyes glued on television with interest, as if I were watching it for the very first time, and I was reduced to tears, yet overjoyed that Kajol and Srk will be back again with My name is Khan. I can't wait for it, and I hope it turns out to be as beautiful, as you made Kuch Kuch Hota Hain.

di
Monday, September 08, 2008 6:44:36 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan...
I LOVE YOU SO MUCH Karan..
________56556789567893789378__ _
________46387354561816181318__ _
________56867893758765987689__ _
_______________575654&________ _
_______________7634566________ _
_______________5643565________ _
_______________7645487________ _
_______________4863133________ _
_______________4689461________ _
_______________8745879________ _
________56556789567893789378__ _
________46387354561816181318__ _
________56867893758765987689__ _
______________________________ _
______________________________ _
______________________________ _
___172254532_______________
_2125445335332588_____________ _
741353322222221388____________ _
4523322222222211246___________ __
03233222222222221111222223499_ ___
641222222222222223355555553250 8___
291222222222222222223333323321 88__
_83122222222222222222222222217 288_
_6911222222222222222222222221_ _485
__831122222222222222222222227_ _388
__58212222222222222222222211__ _088
___80172222222222222222227____ 888_
____867222222222222221______08 88__
____18512222222211_______48888 6___
_____887777__________68888887_ __
______88________508888888_____ _
_______85488888888885_________
______________________________
______________________________
______________________________
___56546_____________78768____
___67887_____________67678____
___68699_____________89899____
___68787_____________74486____
___46786_____________87766____
___78641_____________87545____
___54584_____________48672____
____7978_____________4664_____
____7899_____________7456_____
_____789_____________890______
______90_____________78_______
_______90___________90________
________907_______799_________
__________809___899___________
____________89004_____________
Did you say My massage to Kajol ???????;D(Tina from Iran living in Washington love Kajol so much and she is krazzy for kajol )Thanks again for bringing back magic couple SrKajol...
OMG Karan I saw new picture of Srk new movie Rab ne bana di Jodi’ WOOOOOOOOOOOOW He looks sooooooo hot...He is king khan...and kajol is queen..
love you karan
lots of love...TC


Monday, September 08, 2008 11:20:28 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan,

movie making has taken different strides nowadays. your reviews were ok however, i would like to add that some movies are made with determinaion and grit . its really surprising how the audience reacts to different films . I always wished i could make a movie . With the changing taste of the people , the time has come to experiment diffrent genre of movie making.We have the ability to surpass the best in the world.

Karan , plaese make a western ( a la Clint eastwood flick ) and i know u would do a superb job. i can help u with the story line.

Thanks and regards.

khairul.
khairul hazarika
Monday, September 08, 2008 11:07:09 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan

Rock On! and Jaane Tu.. were the best by far this year, so far..

tell us more about Dostana and Rab Ne Bana di Jodi if possible..

How about replacing "Wake Up Sid!" with "Good Morning Sid!".. i think it sounds more refrenshin with the wish.

God Bless
Arjun
Arjun
Tuesday, September 09, 2008 1:35:00 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan,

Just a suggestion.......Please inform us of your next teaser of Dostana and when is the official music release date .

Movie is out in Nov ..so I'am thinking the music should be out at least 5 to 6 weeks before the movies release date......so early next month.

"Bounce shut up and bounce"....you have talked about Vishal and Shekar have out done them selves......anybody has to out do themselves when they you to deal with.

Your sense of music is impacable.

Great marketing techiques is a key for a succefull movie....I was amazed at the Teaser or trailor of Kal Ho NA Ho...what a master peice...it made you watch the trailor and say..I must go and see this movie.

You had better hang on to the guy or guys who helped you make these excellent trailors.

Yeh Baby!

Tony

tony
Tuesday, September 09, 2008 2:09:45 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi karan
I saw a promo of your movie Dostana WOWOW Thats fantastic Karan I want to see whole movie Karan Im sure it work well for box office and about kuchi kuchi hota hai Im really Happy Srk Kajol and Rani voice it would be great job
and even the best news is My name is khan it will be the best movie for the all of india and it make with jodi number 1 Shahrukh khan and Kajol thats really fantasic and best news for me and all of people
Karan I serious there are more than BILLION fans are waiting for My name is khan to see magic couple srk and kajol
and Karan please make romantic song for SrKajol like suraj hoa madam and some lovely second like srkajol in kkhh in the rain
LoVe YoU kArAn VeRrY vErY mUcH
mahshid
Tuesday, September 09, 2008 2:26:42 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan,
Please do inform us whether you are a part of TEMPTATIONS RELOADED or not. We are eagerly waitin for some news from that front especially from you as you are very close to SRK.

You keep telling us not to ask any quetions regardin MNIK but, by now u must have realised how excited we are about it! Do keep us updated.

WE LOVE YOUR FILMS and my favourite is K3G. I think kANK was a beautiful film.

As far as this year is concerned, i think JODHAA AKBAR and RACE were good. JAANE TU... wasn't that gr8 but it got all the hype coz it was pitted against another big film and was better.

I seriously hope we'll get to enjoy some great fims produced by Dharma in the near future!
RK
Tuesday, September 09, 2008 6:41:34 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
WHHHHHHHHAT?????? I heared of some one that you didnt like UMAH?!!!!!!!! Is that true Karan?????Com on Karan whats the matter? are you really serious????
Kajols performance was really great and I think no one can be like her.
She is really actress and she live with her rolls
Karan whats wrong??????????I just want to know why you didnt like kajol on the movie??????
Im really proud af kajol for u ma aur hum and I really dont know why you didnt like her performance??????!!!!!!!!!!
priyanka & rani & Aish & bipasha & kareena are really great but we all kow they never cant be like KAJOL
and I hope she will win in filmfare...
Oh Karan Im so happy for my name is khan karan thanks alot for bringing back couple number one of bollywood in your movie after 7 years and karan there are so so so many fans for SrKajol to see please do it very soon
MY NAME IS KHAN IS WILL BE THE BEST MOVIE IN THE WORLD
UMAH is the best movie in 2008
and kkhh and k3g are UNFORGETTABLE movie
Thank you Karan
Have a gread day
sheri979
Tuesday, September 09, 2008 10:58:01 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan......
varsha
Tuesday, September 09, 2008 9:20:12 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan,

Whats this whole thing about "Gay angle" in Dostana....while its welcome, .I just hope its been potrayed in the right sense and not like other movies we see everyday where it gets potrayed as a major disorder.......with most of the Indians crusading against abolishing 377, the least the movie makers can do is NOT make funny parodies about gay situations like you did in 'Kal Ho Na Ho'.... we do not expect every movie to be like 'My Brother Nikhil', but we hope the A list movie makers use some sensitivity while projecting it on screen....We do not expect a lot of support coming in from film fraternity (Thanks Celina J..) while bollywood support will make all the difference to the cause, there are ppl like Vikram Seth, Mahesh Dattani , Anbumani Ramdoss who are trying to stand up against 377 and we hope the movies don't ruin it for us. We are sick of seeing the usual cliched "Bobby Darlings" on screen....lets learn to give some more respect....
Mohit
Tuesday, September 09, 2008 10:42:52 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan,

I liked KANK and KKHH (your first movie). You have a flair for touching the right chord at times...

When are you getting married btw? and with whom?
Mz
Wednesday, September 10, 2008 1:14:17 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
How come you write so rarely? If you have made a certain commitment to blog, I think your entries shouldn't be as spaced as they are right now. 30th august, 14th august, 9th august and then somewhere in July.

Hoping to hear from you.

best
Madiha Aijaz
New York/Karachi
Madiha
Wednesday, September 10, 2008 1:16:53 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan,

First of all I want to say I LOVE YOU and so does my whole crew of ABCD's and several non-desis out here in the San Francisco Bay Area. If I can ever win a Koffee With Karan Coffee Hamper, I will die happy!

I think you have such an impressive range as a filmmaker, and a very keen grip on what appeals to our diverse audiences. I like how you are able to push the envelope in a subtle, cheeky, and yet genuinely thought-provoking manner. Therefore it should be no surprise that aside from your obvious mainstream appeal, your movies (and Farah's) have a massive cult following among the queer and queer-friendly audiences out here, and get screened almost annually at the Castro theater in SF -- I'm sure Dostana naturally be next in line. You should come join a screening some time; it is phenomenal!

The one issue I have with Bollywood lately is its continuing and narrowing obsession with thinness and whiteness. As the west becomes more cognizant of the damaging effects of mainstream media on girls' self esteem and body image, it seems like Bollywood is taking more of a plunge in making people feel inadequate in order to push consumerism and product placement. I wish people like Bipasha and Preity who had such nice, voluptuous figures before didn't feel the need to emaciate completely! I feel like that consciousness has yet to come through in Bollywood, and maybe 10 years down the road we'll see celebrities doing more public service announcement type things about how brown is beautiful, real women have curves, nobody naturally has perfect skin, there's so much airbrushing and work done on models and actors, etc. Maybe you should be the one to open this conversation!

BTW I take an academic interest in Bollywood and designed a student-led course on it at UC Berkeley a few years ago; KKHH was of course part of the syllabus: www.geocities.com/bollywood_decal

OK I am done with the dissertation now, LOL.

XOXOXO,
Leena
Wednesday, September 10, 2008 4:02:13 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan,

first I want to say "Thank you very much for keep writing". If you are afraid to write about 'My Name Is Khan' then either you overcome this and write about it (common show more selfconfidence on this) or you do not (this is also okay). It is a decision you must make by your own. But if you tell us more about this film then please do not tell us too much, better make some photos of the actors and bring them online. We all love to see the newest pictures of all of them.

I am sure I will love the film, really. Not only one film made by you has disappointed me, no matter what the story was. So I think you will make a great film this time also and you know this!! So all the best for this!!

By the way I have not seen all the movies you mentioned above but 'Jodhaa Akbar' impressed me a lot. First I was not sure because I do not think that Aishwarya is a great actress but I was surprised because she has done a very good performance in this film. I like her but I always see that some actors and actresses can only make a good performance with a special seccond leading actor. Aishwarya needs someone like Shah Rukh (Devdas) or Hrithik (Jodhaa Akbar), on all other film she disappointed me. It is a pity because I know that she can be better! And also Kajol (I have to say that I love her a lot). She did her best job ever in 'Fanaa' besides Aamir Khan. What for a film. It shows us Kajol in a different way and better than ever before. I hope you saw the movie and do not let happen that she falls back in the Anjali-Style of 'Kabhi Khushi Khabhie Gham' or 'Kuch Kuch Hota Hai'. I love both films, but I think this Anjali-time for Kajol is over now. Her roles have to be more serious. Little jokes are okay but not too much.

Now after I said that, I can understand why you are afraid of talking about 'My Name Is Khan'. We are more critcal than before, tha whole audience has changed a bit. You do not only make the films for an Indian audience but for worldwide cinema. But You have made films before, which where different, I think of 'Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna' which has an end the audience did not really expexted. And so I think you will make a very good job with this movie and surprise us again. I hope so. (but I do not want to miss the music?!, please)

I read all this comments and I am a little bit surprised because of the questions about your private life. If I were you I would have been shocked because it is a little bit like interfering in personal matters. I think that is something what happens when you are a famous person. Do not feel forced to talk about those topics if you do not want to.

So dear Karan, I say see you next time (I do not say good bye - you see we learn something about hope from you films), Take care about you your friends and your cute good children.
With lots of love
Kathy
Kathy
Wednesday, September 10, 2008 5:43:39 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan!

Maybe this year wasnt the best year for Bollywood, but definitely not a forgettable one.I guess you have missed out on some real gems realesed this year.All me to list a few of them.
First one being Aamir - A common man caught in an uncommon situation, a one day film, shot in the most crowded places in mumbai, a new actor in bollywood and a new director.
Second being Mumbai Meri Jaan - The after effects of Mumbai train blasts.Yet again, a common man facing terrorism.
Such films cannot be compared with huge budget films like Jodha-Akbar or Rock On, who have this huge budget to make huge film sets and can spend huge amounts on promoting their films.
Just a suggestion, do takeout time and check out these movies which are actually realistic.Maybe you will change your opinion about "Not a great year for Bollywood".

-Pari
Pari
Wednesday, September 10, 2008 6:56:40 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan...I would like to share a small video that I & my hubby composed on the instrumental of 'Kal Ho the Ho'......not sure if u'll have the time to watch it but I'll appreciate if u do...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQN0o9EtteI

Love ur 'Koffee with karan' shows... waiting for Season 3....
Take care...
subarna
Wednesday, September 10, 2008 10:55:41 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I have to agree with you that it hasn't been the best year for indian cinema but it hasn't been the worst either. 4-5 years ago, not many movies were released and the ones that were, were pretty lame plots. I have to give it to Indian cinema for the different story lines they come up with to keep people going back. I am such a bollywood junkie but this is the first year i have found myself going to watch indian movies at teh cinema so frequently. The movies are the cutsie lovey dovey type love stories that have a good plot, new actors that can actually act, and just good entertainment. There hasn't been a single movie where i have walked out of the theatre saying to myself, oh god why did i waste my time coming here, what a rubbish movie. Instead i find myself saying, oh it was cute, or it was nice, and it was worth watching once.

Perhaps you are being too harsh by saying it was the worst year, because in my opinion the worst years were in teh past, and the movies now are not that bad. In the past, they wouldn't have the best sets, the story lines were terrible and the humor was extremely stupid. Things have changed with time. There is more of a modern twist to stories these days and there is more creativity that is put into dialog and plot. Movies released this year are what i would say worth watchign once, and that's it.

However, i do agree that there hasn't been a movie like KKHH, KHNO, DDLJ, that would make your jaw drop and rave about the movie while leaving the theatre. SO like everyone else i am definitely looking forward for another WOW movie like the above mentioned.

One thing that scares me is in the future, i see Bollywood and Hollywood kind of becoming one. Where you'll have foreign actresses playing a lead role in an indian movie and Indian actors playing a role in a foreign movie. I'm not so worried about the Indian actors playing roles in HW, but more so the opposite.

I live in the US but i watch indian movies to be in touch with my culture. That's how i learned to speak hindi is by watching Hindi movies for the past 10 years and i would hate to see Snoop Dogg rapping in Indian movies, and i would hate to see English dialogs in an indian movie. And i sure as heck would not want to see a figure like Britney even do a scene in a BW movie. But for some reason, i see the integration of the 2 industries coming together in the near future and if not in the next few years definitely in the next 10 years. I can almost put my finger on it.

BTW - i just got back from Cancun, Mexico and think its a GORGEOUS place for a set. It's much nicer than Miami. Check out my pictures of Cancun if you get a chance. It's gorgeous. Just something to think about.

=)

Me
(California, USA)
Thursday, September 11, 2008 3:52:51 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I actually haven't seen any 2008 Hindi films - except for Race, which wasn't exactly the best movie ever. >_> I'll be sure to see the three you listed! I've been meaning to see Jodhaa-Akbar and JTYJN for ages, so I'm glad to hear they're good.

And, er, I hope you're kidding about the Botox! Botoxed people often end up looking frightening ratehr than youthful.

And since you won't tell us anything about My Name Is Khan, how about some info on Koochie Koochie Hota Hai? Like, I know SRK, Kajol, and Rani are reprising their roles (yay!), but are any other of the original actors (Salman Khan, Farida Jalal, Anupam Kher, etc.)? How different is it from the original KKHH? And, most importantly, will the star-counting Sikh boy stil be there?? <3 Basically, anything you can tell us about this movie would be appreciated!
Caitlin
Thursday, September 11, 2008 10:59:49 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
RESPECTED KARAN
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
UNITE
SRK AND MR BACHCHAN
Thursday, September 11, 2008 8:15:42 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
hi karan.........why do u all t time get lost fm ur blog???????????this blog is dead.......no action at all..........today after waiting sooooo long for ur new writeup,i chanced upon mr.bachchan's blog dated11th sep....i could not help posting a comment immediately.......he is truly the KING.......if king can write everyday n acknowledge his FANS N AC'S then u r the uncrowned PRINCE who should learn something fm such a great man..........aab leekho......ps......saw u at one launch do ......why torn jeans??i didnt say go RUGGED BUT CAUSAL........oops......kya karoo my nature is such i lov bak-bak....
KAVITA
Thursday, September 11, 2008 9:51:58 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
You haven't considered A Wednesday in the list it by far was the best .
Friday, September 12, 2008 3:02:19 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Dear Karan: I read your blog and sometimes reply. I'm not sure how comments are approved and displayed. But I am sure there are many more replies than what gets posted. I too live in America and would have to travel (one day) if I were to see a hindi movie. Thanks to the the internet I have access to Bollywood. I must say, I have enjoyed reading more comments for "The fate of 2008". Indian cinema always puts a smile on my face, unlike any other movie. Only the best of wishes to you and your productions.
ki
Friday, September 12, 2008 6:42:39 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Saba

I would also like Karan to direct Aamir with Ash together.

Akshaye too has matured as an actor.

I'd also like Karan to direct all my other favourties such as Abhishek, Sanjay Dutt too.

I wonder if Karan can manage to pull off another multistarrer with all these actors again?

SRK and Ash were great together in all their movies.
Sonya
Friday, September 12, 2008 5:40:43 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey! karan. I am a huge fan of you and srk. karan i want you to write about why the industry hates srk??? I get really sad when anyone speaks against him. I read somewhere that he tried to sabotage the bachan tour??? then spat with salman? then akshay and amir. I am such a hug fan of srk however these news give me second thoughts about him. Why??? I really need you to comment on this.
Sara shahzad
Saturday, September 13, 2008 12:42:53 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
'The Mumbai in Mumbai Cutting is a world inhabited by you and me not the one where Karan Johar resides.'

http://www.buzz18.com/reviews/movies/review-mumbai-cutting/70041/2

This is an excerpt from the review of 'Mumbai Cutting' - set of eleven short films screen at OSIAN festival recently. If you haven't come across it, I thought it would be interesting hear how you respond to this frequently surfacing criticism about your plush sets, candy floss romance and some what contrived sense of reality you seem to espouse. I remember when you spoke to Mira Nair on your show, she also listed the same reservations about your cinematic sensibilities. If I remember correctly, she talked about how she found it difficult to get used to the american winters and how it led to conceive this scene in Name Sake where Tabu is dragging laundry in the snow, wearing her husband's winter clothes. While you always show immigrants (I am not using the word NRI here cuz there are whole bunch of us who are from Pakistan or Bangladesh etc) living perfect life, in perfect harmony and in their perfect houses.

It is a pleasant surprise to see your film list for this year, judging by the kind of films that you make which more or less subscribe to the escapist brand, I am glad that you appreciate sensible cinema, if you only you would make some as well.

From your list of productions, 'Wake up Sid' sounds good. Congratulations on going towards the path less travelled.

P.S: I hope you write more often. I really enjoy reading your posts.

Madiha Aijaz |Karachi/New York|

Madiha
Saturday, September 13, 2008 3:36:22 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hi Karan...
KajoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOooOoOoOoOoOoOooOoOoOoOoL She is the best...
Please Karan say us some thing about Kajol in My name is khan...
OH Karan I heared Manish will designing for Kajol in My name is khan WOOW!!!!! .......
Love you A LOT...
SrKajol are made for each other
they are REALLY MAGIC 4 EVER
Kajol QUEEN and Shahrukh KING
Lots of love................................Tina
Saturday, September 13, 2008 10:57:52 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I'm so excited that part of the MNIK shooting is going to be in San Francisco -- it's about time! :) Please post when you will be here so your fans can stalk you!
Saturday, September 13, 2008 11:28:35 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
There was no me long. I left on the just holiday at last. I surrendered first time since several years without the shadow of the remorses to blissful laziness. The hot sun Italii, beach , warm sea , gentle September breeze i. .....nothing beyond this. By I almost two weeks did not receive telephones , I did not watch the television, I did not walk to the cinema, I did not even touch the computer !!! Amazing !!! Complete, miraculous , laziness. My organism several first days tried to recover through the continuously dream. I slept everywhere I :in the hotel, on the beach , only tried to persevere over the plate. Though this easy was not -)) I charged batteries After certain time when, mine approached to the work „internal I”. It more and more insistingly demanded the dialogue. What pushing new subjects to meditations move. Did not have strength to fight with him, his surrendered now he prefers. I lightly irritated the affected on me intellectual work decided to take over the argumentation in the latter part of second week and what was successful to internet little cafe more quickly, where I caught up my post office with the wild desire. I conducted selections in first order quickly and removed litters, to to occupy myself from genuine the pleasure then proper the reading.
How do you think which letters I read as first? Not, you do not make a mistake these which they were connected with India or from Bollywood. One of letters caused me the largest pleasure, information was this from „Dharmy..”informing about the accomplished new registration by Karan. I had amazing the full consciousness, that the letter is one from many information what the device sends and however the heart began me more quickly and greedily to beat on the sound itself of the word Dharma I absorbed these two commonplace sentences. Why? When the evening sipping the excellent wine I sat down to the supper in my favourite restaurant near the sounds of romantic Italian music I came back thoughts to questions what it placed me „internal I”in the morning. Looking for answers on many bothering one chained „us”questions „our”attention on longer. And namely for who for what we practically do what we do. For who? what ? Mole's Karan films, for who? what? I pick information, I browse after books, do I watch the thousands of films For who etc.? How do you think? FOR ONESELF ! They did not tell anything, we do this all for oneself. Because we love this cinema, because we love the climate Bollywood. The sound of the word Dharma wakes in me such emotions for this. Bollywood lives each of us, every one wants to feel his part. That is why information from the favourite manufacturer - the light thrill calls out the director. Nobody does like being anonymous, every one wants to feel that he coexists with his idols for this. It is proper Karan instead of Dear for this maybe, to address to every one by name. Their , such such directness in reports with fans subjectivize increases the tie and so essential builds but the brotherhood. So not many and as many! And let's thank you for our egoism, because if it was not for he our work did not have the right existence.
I greet
...
Sunday, September 14, 2008 2:39:32 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I like interesting messages which are posted here by users.
I see, that your popularity, mr Johar, left far beyond India.
These are the USA, Europe, Asia.
I have not found the republic of South Africa, for example, or Australia. But I think, that this misunderstanding will pass soon.

To visitors.
Let's speak about really interesting things.
SRK and Big B, or requests to say Kajol some is lovely, but it is not interesting.
I understand desperate attempts to use each possible channel to make the way to an adored Star.
Unfortunately, I am not familiar with Bollywood's bohemia strongly, I do not know many actors, and about Mr. Karan I have found out, having read his script of " Kal Ho Na Ho ".
I'll be a student of cinematology faculty in this spring (VGIK).
And I read many different works now.
Mr. Karan has interested me as the author, and it would be interesting to me to communicate on different themes about creativity, but only not about worship idols.


Have a nice day, guys

With sincerity,
Ann
Sunday, September 14, 2008 11:16:57 PM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Hey Karan
How are you?whats up?
let me say some thing about My Nmae Is Khan:
Karan every one konw Shahrukh and Kajol are best friend for each other and every one know shahrukh and kajol are magic couple and we know they are best jodi and karan you know how many people are waitinig to see them togeather but why you dont say some thing about them for My Name is khan Karan I know you cant say but have you really think about their fans???they should to wait all the time??
we wait 7 years is not anogh !!!!!!!
every day every hours evry second of life we big fans of SRKAJOL have to wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait wait.
when we can see our favorite jodi number 1
you are the once that just you can back them and we know just you win to Reconcile Kajol
and for the last thing my Request of you is please karan come back them very soon
we fans are really deaing long time we didnt see SrKajol please karan


S_khodayari
Monday, September 15, 2008 4:07:11 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
Karan, if I am dying and granted a wish, I would want to see a movie featuring Shahrukh and Aamir. We are most unfortunate not to witness these two great actors on screen even once yet. Can't you host a Koffee show and get these two stalwarts back together for public. The publc have made them superstars. Don't you think they desrve to get this in return. We are not asking for a movie. Is is possible that we can see Shahrukh and Aamir together on TV screen, leave alone the silver screen. For gods sake and public demand.. Please.................
muzamil beigh
Monday, September 15, 2008 4:44:07 AM (India Standard Time, UTC+05:30)
I am pained to see the way media potraying Shahrukh. Throwing mud on his image, defaming him, insecurity getting aroused by his other jealous costarts spitting venom on Shahrukh. You tell me what was the need for Akshay to tell that I only think there is one king and he is amitabh. Did the king tag was attached to Shahrukh by himself. This bloody media gave it and now they are after that innocent Shahrukh who looks culrpit in all those controversies.
Anand Singh
All comments require the approval of the site owner before being displayed.
Name
E-mail
Home page

 

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

Live Comment Preview
<March 2010>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
28123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031123
45678910
Images courtesy of Timond Watches